Paul St-Pierre Plamondon is defending Alberta Premier Danielle Smith over her government’s planned referendum question on separation, pushing back against criticism from Prime Minister Mark Carney.
Speaking Tuesday, the Parti Québécois (PQ) leader said Smith is “just doing her job” by proposing to consult Albertans on whether to pursue a future vote on sovereignty.
His comments come after Carney sharply criticized the idea Monday, calling separation campaign promises a “very dangerous bluff” based on his experience with Brexit, when the U.K. voted to leave the European Union.
Plamondon said he was surprised by Carney’s remarks, arguing they were out of line.
“For Mark Carney to all of a sudden start saying that it’s a bluff, it’s dangerous, I think it’s really out of line,” he told reporters in Quebec City. “We are free to consult our population at any time.”
He added that Quebec’s own legal and political history supports the right to hold referendums, pointing to the province’s two past sovereignty votes and longstanding principle that its population can be consulted on its future.
Get daily National news
Alberta’s government has said it will hold a referendum this fall asking residents whether the province should remain in Canada or begin the process toward a binding vote on separation.
Carney, who served as governor of the Bank of England during the 2016 Brexit referendum, warned that campaigns suggesting separation is a low-risk or strategic move can mislead voters.
“In these separation issues, it is often advanced that vote for this and it’s a free option… That is a very dangerous bluff,” he said, adding that the U.K. is still grappling with the consequences many years after the vote.
He said he plans to campaign for Canadian unity, emphasizing economic and social benefits of remaining in the federation, including access to large markets and shared social programs.
The comments come as federal and provincial leaders gather in Alberta for the western premiers’ conference, where economic co-operation and interprovincial relations are expected to be key topics.
- Son of slain Lumby woman testifies in 2nd-degree murder trial of Vitali Stefanski
- B.C. First Nation wants treaty process paused or they could exercise civil disobedience
- Saskatoon researchers in ‘very early stages’ of animal testing for hantavirus vaccine
- Reported Germany-Canada LNG deal would bolster investment case for Ksi Lisims: David Eby
Plamondon’s comments on Tuesday also underscore the PQ’s own sovereigntist agenda. The party, currently leading in the polls ahead of Quebec’s Oct. 5 provincial election, has pledged to hold a referendum during its first mandate if elected.
The PQ has long advocated for Quebec independence, arguing the province should have full control over its laws, economy and international relations. Quebec has held two referendums on sovereignty, in 1980 and 1995, with the latter narrowly rejecting independence.
Plamondon said the same principle applies in Alberta.
“I’m pretty sure that it’s the same reasoning in Alberta right now,” he said.
Quebec Premier Christine Fréchette was asked by reporters Friday if she thought what was going on in Alberta would fuel Quebec’s separatism movement. “We’ll let Albertans decide for themselves,” she said.
She did not comment on weather she believes it will have an impact on Quebec’s sovereigntist movement.
-
![]()
Carney compares Alberta separatism to Brexit, calls it a ‘dangerous bluff’ -
![]()
Alberta is ‘at the centre’ of efforts to improve Canada: Carney -
![]()
Poilievre pushes motion for PM Carney, Liberals to scrap all federal gas taxes in 2026 -
![]()
Carney warns Alberta separation referendum question is ‘dangerous bluff’ -
![]()
‘It’s really out of line’: Paul St-Pierre Plamondon on Carney calling separatism vote a ‘dangerous bluff’ -
![]()
Will Carney, Eby see eye-to-eye on Alberta pipeline project?
As you should all know by now, I’m no fan of Kay-Bec, However, I MUST agree with the P. Q. leader’s defence of Alberta’s plan to ask both the question and more than that the right of the people to hold a vote on such an important issue. This issue is to damn important for politicians to decide for the people. The people must decide their future for themselves. End of Story.
The End. Good-Luck and Good-Bye.