B.C. court hears appeal for convicted double child-killer Andrew Berry

Click to play video: 'Appeal hearing underway for convicted child killer Andrew Berry' Appeal hearing underway for convicted child killer Andrew Berry
A four-day appeal hearing is underway for the Oak Bay man convicted of murdering his two young daughters on Christmas Day more than four years ago. It's being held in Vancouver and - due to strong interest from media and the public - it's also being live-streamed to a courtroom in Victoria. Reporter Kristen Robinson was at Monday's hearing – Jun 20, 2022

An appeal for the father convicted of murdering his two daughters on Christmas Day 2017 in Oak Bay, B.C., got underway at the B.C. Court of Appeals in Vancouver on Monday.

Andrew Berry was found guilty on two counts of second-degree murder in the killing of six-year-old Chloe Berry and four-year-old Aubrey Berry, and sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 22 years in December, 2019.

Click to play video: 'Oak Bay father sentenced for murders of his two young daughter' Oak Bay father sentenced for murders of his two young daughter
Oak Bay father sentenced for murders of his two young daughter – Dec 19, 2019

Berry was found with multiple stab wounds in the bathtub of his apartment, while his two daughters were found stabbed to death in their beds.

Story continues below advertisement

Read more: Minimum 22-year sentence for B.C. father convicted of murdering daughters on Christmas

At trial, prosecutors argued Berry’s wounds were self-inflicted, and that he had killed the girls after hitting rock bottom over a gambling addiction that left him unable to pay his bills, and fear of losing custody of the girls to his ex-partner.

A jury rejected Berry’s defence that he was actually attacked by a “dark-skinned” man linked to a loan shark named “Paul,” to whom he owed a major gambling debt.

Click to play video: 'Mother describes devastating loss of daughters' Mother describes devastating loss of daughters
Mother describes devastating loss of daughters – Dec 17, 2019

Appeals are not fresh trials, and the B.C. Court of Appeal does not re-examine the facts of a case but rather rules on whether there were errors made in the application of the law.

On Monday, Berry’s lawyer Tim Russel told the justices John Hunter, Patrice Abiroux and Joyce DeWitt-Van Oosten his client was appealing on three grounds.

Story continues below advertisement

Russel argued trial judge Miriam Gropper erred in her charge to the jury, that she erred in in a ruling about the influence of statements Berry made in the presence of firefighters, paramedics and health-care workers at the crime scene and hospital, and that police investigation subsequent trial process were inadequate.

Read more: Andrew Berry found guilty of killing his two daughters Christmas Day 2017

Russell argued Friday that while in hospital and being held under the Mental Health Act, Berry’s charter rights were violated because he wasn’t informed of his right to silence.

“In a pure mental health context, you have a right to silence,” he told the court.

He argued police knowingly allowed a doctor to take Berry’s statements, and that the doctor had “knowledge Berry was going to be prosecuted.”

During Berry’s trial in B.C. Supreme Court, the firefighter who found Berry in his bathtub testified he thought he heard Berry say “leave me alone” and “kill me.”

Click to play video: 'Jury returns verdict in Andrew Berry trial' Jury returns verdict in Andrew Berry trial
Jury returns verdict in Andrew Berry trial – Sep 26, 2019

Russell also argued that during Berry’s trial, Justice Gropper was “patently incorrect” in her finding that paramedics and firefighters were “not persons of authority” who could influence the prosecution.

Story continues below advertisement

“The trial judge doesn’t adequately explain why firefighters and paramedics couldn’t have had the ability to influence the prosecution,” Russell argued.

“Firefighters and paramedics (were) clearly acting in concert with police.”

Read more: ‘Just kill me’: Week 3 of Oak Bay double-murder trial hears disturbing new testimony

Russell made similar arguments about Berry’s statement to a nurse while subsequently in hospital.

At several points Russell faced interjections from the judges asking him to identify what legal error he was arguing.

The Crown is slated to respond to Russell’s arguments beginning Tuesday afternoon ,with four days set aside for the appeal hearing.

-With files from Kristen Robinson

Sponsored content