January 8, 2019 12:58 am
Updated: January 8, 2019 5:41 pm

Record amount of Canadian oil exported by rail raises safety concerns

WATCH: The amount of oil being shipped in Canada by rail has skyrocketed recently to record levels, experts say, and as Heather Yourex-West reports, that's raising concerns around safety in Calgary.​

A A

Canadian crude oil exports by rail have skyrocketed to record levels, raising safety concerns amid the boom.

Story continues below

In October 2017, Canada exported 137,178 barrels per day, according to National Energy Board statistics.

By May 2018, it was 198,788 barrels per day.

Then, in October 2018, rail exports hit a record high at 327,229 barrels per day — a 138.5 per cent volume increase in one year.

READ MORE: Alberta to purchase rail cars to move oil without feds: Notley

“The volume comes with the territory of being a successful place,” said Gian-Carlo Carra, a Calgary city councillor. “As we know, we don’t have pipelines to take Alberta products to tidewater and we’re going to be doing a lot of the heavy lifting with the rail infrastructure we have — and we’re very lucky to have such robust, nation-building infrastructure in the centre of our inland port.”

He said this oil conversation is akin to ones he has with Calgary residents about traffic volumes.

“It’s not volume that’s the issue. It’s speed that’s the issue,” Carra said. “We want to make sure that as more and more people move around and more and more products are moved around on rail that we’re becoming safer and safer and safer, and more environmentally sensitive.”

READ MORE: No risk to public safety after CP train derails in southeast Calgary: officials

After CP tanker cars came off the tracks in Calgary near 30 Avenue S.E. at Alyth Road S.E. on Sunday, the Transportation Safety Board of Canada has opened an investigation. No product spilled in the incident.

Carra said that Sunday’s derailment was significant in that it highlighted a positive working relationship between all parties involved: CP Rail, firefighters, federal boards and different levels of government.

“It was low impact in the sense that they were empty cars but high impact in the sense that they went off the rails in a very sculptural way,” Carra said.

A CP train came off the tracks in southeast Calgary on Sunday.

Mike Hills/Global News

Ryan Gill’s marketing firm, Communo, neighbours the tracks. He hasn’t noticed the increase in tanker traffic and isn’t worried anyway because he said the trains move slowly.

“How else are they supposed to move the oil with no pipeline?” Gill said.

Concordia University professor Ming Yuan Chen and PhD student Omar Abuobidalla have been researching how to make hazardous goods rail transport safer since the 2014 train derailment and fatal explosion in Lac-Mégantic.

Smoke rises from railway cars that were carrying crude oil after derailing in downtown Lac-Megantic, Que., Saturday, July 6, 2013.

THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson

The researchers are hoping to reduce accident potential, but if they occur, then the goal is to reduce the negative impact on people.

Abuobidalla said population areas and how they change over time have to be considered.

“It should be some relation between how much we transport and this team,” he said. “We have to increase the staff in the emergency response team.”

READ MORE: 5 years after Lac-Megantic tragedy claimed 47 lives, $133M rail bypass to be built

Chen said rail cars containing dangerous goods should avoid heavily-populated areas — but if that’s not an option, extra caution is necessary.

“From the knowledge that I have, it’s less risky using pipelines to transport the liquid material, if possible,” Chen said.

A pipeline is the safest and cheapest method to move oil; railway is the second cheapest way, he said.

“If you increase the amount of transportation, sooner or later you will have some incidents that will be happening,” Chen said.

Crude oil, and other petroleum products, is transported in rail tanker cars on a Canadian Pacific Railway (CPR) train near Medicine Hat, Alberta, Canada on Thurs., Sept. 6, 2018.

THE CANADIAN PRESS IMAGES/Larry MacDougal

Under the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Act and the Railway Safety Act, there are no limits to how much oil can be shipped by rail.

Transport Canada said safety rules have been improved with lower permitted speeds, hastened phase-out timelines for older tanker cars, more rail safety inspections and stronger rail tank car standards.

READ MORE: Rail cars for oil transport ‘not going to solve the problem’ for Alberta: Scheer

“Transport Canada has also taken significant actions to enhance public safety and further improve the safety of transporting dangerous goods by rail under the pillars of prevention, effective response and accountability,” a statement to Global News read.

© 2019 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error

Comments

Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.