A Canadian Journal of Public Health study says while “support for, and use of, spanking may be declining in Canada,” 20 per cent of Gen Z and millennial parents still use it.
The research, published last week, says that when Canadian parents aged 18 to 27 (Gen Zs) and millennial parents (ages 28 to 42) were asked whether they have ever spanked their child or children on their bottom with their hand, about 20 per cent said “yes.”
“The prevalence of spanking history among Canadian adults is high,” the study states.
The study is the first of its kind to provide details on the national landscape of spanking.
How do Canadians see spanking?
The researchers found that “having a history of being spanked as a child was associated with increasing odds of spanking one’s own child.”
Out of the 4,000 surveyed adults, when asked about perceptual beliefs about spanking, 15 per cent of parents overall believe “it is necessary to use spanking to properly raise a child.”
Get daily National news
More than 72 per cent “did not support this belief,” 10.6 per cent stated they did not know and 1.8 per cent said they preferred not to answer.
In addition, 55.6 per cent of parents reported experiencing being spanked (three times or more) as a child, 40.2 per cent indicated they were spanked between none and two times, while 3.6 per cent reported not knowing about their spanking history.
Those most likely to spank are mothers (74.5 per cent), while fathers voiced similar but slightly lower support (73.4 per cent).
Among those who were spanked, 22.6 per cent reported it “leaving a mark or a bruise or causing lasting physical pain.”
A 2022 BMC Public Health study conducted in Manitoba found 18.5 per cent of parents and 22 per cent of adolescents “agreeing with the statement that spanking is a normal part of parenting.”
Seventy countries or states “have legally banned corporal punishment in all settings.”
The researchers concluded that the data collected “show some positive indication that support for, and use of, spanking may be declining in Canada.”
While there is no Canadian law that makes spanking illegal, the Supreme Court has imposed limits, including age restrictions.
Section 43 of the Canadian Criminal Code states that “every schoolteacher, parent or person standing in the place of a parent is justified in using force by way of correction toward a pupil or child, as the case may be, who is under his care, if the force does not exceed what is reasonable under the circumstances.”
However, the study found that “a substantial proportion of experiences of spanking contravene the law, which only permits the use of ‘reasonable force’ by way of correction toward a child between the ages of two and 12 years, where the corrective force is minor (i.e., not leaving a mark or causing injury).”
The researchers say they believe their work shows “the need to repeal Sect. 43 of the Canadian Criminal Code to protect children and explicitly prohibit all forms of legalized violence against children.”
I’ve seen kids that are never spanked and I’ve seen kids that have been spanked and there is a clear difference. If a child knows they can do whatever hey want without being punished with pain then they’ll try to get away with more. I only spanked my child for a short period. Just long enough for his to know that if he miss behaves enough it could happen again. And I’m happy to say he’s never been so bad he deserved being spanked again. It’s gotten close a few times but knowing he could be spanked has stopped him from taking it too far. You don’t need to spank long for your child to get that it COULD happen again. I wish my parents did a lot of things differently but spanking me has never been one of them. If your kid doesn’t ever be a punk ass without spanking then congrats but I’m telling you that’s not the norm. Kids will try to get away with anything and they need to know there are consequences for their actions. I’ve never had someone say they were never spanked and be surprised by it. It’s easy to tell when someone’s never been spanked.
I was spanked, wooden spoon, flyswatter on the hand. Did not grow up hating my parents. My dad and I are very close decades later. I grew up to have a successful career and kids of my own. Correction by way of spanking is only one part of parenting. I really only think it applies from 2-4yo. After 4 when their language and mental processing is more developed there are many other equally or more effective means to correct bad behavior; as well as model and reinforce good behavior.
The “how dare” pearl-clutching crowd are the ones whos kids I see drop out of highschool, become addicts etc.
Slow down GLOBAL….I will discipline my Children however I see fit…with zero interference from the state
As a mother of a 2.5 year old, I will testify that there are other methods to discipline that actually teach the child skills vs using violence. It takes work because most of us were not raised in emotionally healthy households. Spanking children is lazy and abusive parenting.
“10.6 per cent stated they did not know”
Um, this is a yes/no question with no right answer. No wonder this country is in a steep downward spiral.
How appalling that adults would ever consider hitting a child (or anyone, for that matter), a child! Someone smaller with no control over their environment or the people around them. No wonder the world is such a violent place.
How and why I discipline my children is no one else’s business
By the way Global, don’t ever tell me to ‘slow down’ on my comments.
I was spanked, wooden spoon, etc repeatedly as a child. I hate my parents for it. Still angry. How dare a grown adult harm a child that way. My son is 24. Successful and happy. Never spanked once. If you have bad kids it’s because you’re a bad parent.