NATO countries’ bickering over defence budgets likely to dominate summit

Click to play video: 'Canadian defence budget under scrutiny ahead of NATO’s 70th anniversary'
Canadian defence budget under scrutiny ahead of NATO’s 70th anniversary
WATCH ABOVE: Leaders of NATO member nations are meeting this week for the treaty's 70th anniversary. But as Mike Le Couteur explains, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau will have to reassure allies that Canada is pulling its weight and is a strong reliable partner – Dec 2, 2019

Despite pleas to set aside bickering over military spending so the issue doesn’t dominate a third NATO summit in a row, the United States is almost certain to demand again this week that its 28 NATO partners respect their pledges to boost defence budgets.

NATO countries slashed spending as tensions eased after the Cold War. But Russia’s 2014 annexation of Ukraine’s Crimean Peninsula was a wake-up call. The allies agreed then to halt cuts, boost budgets and move toward spending 2 per cent of gross domestic product on defence by 2024.

The 2 per cent figure is perhaps too simplistic in that its value fluctuates depending on how economies perform. Moreover, countries calculate their defence budgets differently; some want veterans pensions included, for example.

Correct spending levels don’t guarantee that adequate forces can be deployed into battle in a timely way and sustained by efficient supply lines. Nor do they have a relationship to any real security threat assessment.

Story continues below advertisement
Click to play video: 'NATO celebration over 70 years marred by concern over organization’s future'
NATO celebration over 70 years marred by concern over organization’s future

READ MORE: NATO’s future in question as Trudeau, world leaders mark alliance’s 70th birthday

Importantly, this is about national military budgets, not NATO funding. No one owes the United States money, even though Washington spends more on defence than all the other allies combined.

That said, European allies and Canada rely heavily on U.S. equipment like large military transport planes and air-to-air refueling, and NATO’s deterrent effect is more credible backed by the United States.

Nine countries are projected to meet the 2 per cent benchmark this year — the U.S. with about 3.4 per cent, Greece, Britain, Bulgaria, Estonia, Poland, Latvia, Lithuania and Romania — up from three nations in 2014. Germany will spend 1.35 per cent, ranking it 17th, but it aims to hit 1.5 per cent by the deadline. Spain, Belgium and Luxembourg spend less than 1 per cent.

Story continues below advertisement

While budgets have risen since 2014, NATO headquarters chooses to use 2016 — the year Donald Trump was elected U.S. president— as its reference point for spending increases. Officials concede privately that this is to mollify Trump.

Click to play video: 'National defence expert not optimistic Canada will meet percentage of GDP target'
National defence expert not optimistic Canada will meet percentage of GDP target

According to new numbers released on Friday, European Allies and Canada will add $130 billion to their defence budgets by the end of 2020. Germany will account for around 20 per cent of that increase. A total of some $400 billion more is expected to be added by 2024.

Germany, the main victim of Trump’s ire, says its current spending meets NATO planning requirements, and plans to spend 2 per cent by around 2031.

Click to play video: 'Trudeau arrives in London ahead of NATO summit'
Trudeau arrives in London ahead of NATO summit

Aside from national budgets, NATO also has a smaller in-house budget worth around $2 billion to run the organization’s headquarters in Brussels and provide some common funding to military operations around the world.

Story continues below advertisement

NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said Thursday that the United States will in future pay less into that pot, with Germany helping to fill the gap. He said Washington and Berlin will pay “roughly 16 per cent” each of the total budget going forward. The U.S. was previously the biggest contributor, paying about 22 per cent. Other European allies will also pay more, apart from France, which has refused.

Sponsored content