Advertisement

Supreme Court ruling on New Brunswick man’s border-beer battle could change Confederation

The Supreme Court of Canada will make a key ruling on Thursday on interprovincial trade, in a case that began when Gerard Comeau was stopped by police with 14 cases of beer and three bottles of liquor in his trunk. File/ Global News

A New Brunswick retiree who just wanted to buy cheaper suds is about to find out if his 2012 beer run to Quebec will change the nature of Confederation.

The Supreme Court of Canada is to make a key ruling Thursday on interprovincial trade, in a case that began when Gerard Comeau was stopped by police with 14 cases of beer and three bottles of liquor in his trunk.

“I’m a Canadian citizen. I can go and shop wherever I want. You can buy clothes, shoes, jewellery, everything and bring it over. How come beer is limited?” Comeau said Wednesday from his home in Tracadie, a small community in the northeast of the province.

The low-key, 64-year-old retired NB Power linesman was fined nearly $300.

READ MORE: New Brunswick man acquitted on charges of illegally importing beer from Quebec

But a New Brunswick trial judge ruled that the charge violated constitutional law, overturning a ban on bringing alcohol across provincial boundaries.

Story continues below advertisement

It quickly became a test case with wide implications.

Comeau’s lawyer has said the ruling could have the power to shift a host of laws across the country governing everything from selling chickens to how engineers and other professionals work across provincial lines. Some trade experts have said a Comeau victory could trigger lawsuits across the country seeking to dismantle similar government-run corporations for cannabis.

Many provinces have intervened in the case against Comeau, while a team of lawyers with an interest in the constitutional issues offered to represent him for free, and the Canadian Constitution Foundation volunteered its assistance.

WATCH: ‘Free the Beer’ case now before Supreme Court

Click to play video '‘Free the Beer’ case now before Supreme Court' ‘Free the Beer’ case now before Supreme Court
‘Free the Beer’ case now before Supreme Court – Dec 7, 2017

He said he never would have been able to afford the legal fight without the help.

Story continues below advertisement

“Any of these big cases they’ll drag it and drag it until you’re out of money and have to give up,” he said.

At issue is a section of the New Brunswick Liquor Control Act prohibiting anyone in the province from having more than 12 pints of beer not purchased through a liquor store in the province.

The trial judge said the law is at odds with Section 121 of the Constitution Act, which reads “All articles of the growth, produce, or manufacture of any one of the provinces shall, from and after the union, be admitted free into each of the other provinces.”

Judge Ronald LeBlanc said the original framers of the Constitution never intended that laws should blatantly block the free flow of goods within their new country.

WATCH: N.B. cross border alcohol case heads back to court

Click to play video 'N.B. cross boarder alcohol case heads back to court' N.B. cross boarder alcohol case heads back to court
N.B. cross boarder alcohol case heads back to court – Oct 13, 2016

During that trial, a senior vice-president of the New Brunswick Liquor Corp., said Quebec prices are cheaper because the producers deal directly with the retailers and the government doesn’t add a mark-up.

Story continues below advertisement

He said in New Brunswick, where the sale of liquor must be through NB Liquor outlets, the corporation adds a mark-up of as much as 89.8 per cent.

READ MORE: New Brunswick government says border-beer sales could ‘redesign’ Canadian federalism

The New Brunswick government has argued that the case threatens to end Canadian federalism as it was originally conceived. But Comeau said his interest is more personal.

“I want to know about me as an individual. Can I go and buy whatever I want, wherever I want and take it home? It’s a simple question. That’s what I want to know,” he said.

Comeau said he continues to buy cheaper beer in Quebec – as recently as last weekend.

“It doesn’t change my life much. I’m still Gerard Comeau,” he said laughing.

Comeau is also hoping to finally be reimbursed for the trunkload of alcohol that was seized more than five years ago.