A new Vancouver city councillor and former legal advocate for tenants says the discovery that landlords have been fined $90,000 after they subdivided a single-family home into a rooming house operation is sad — but not too surprising.
“The practices that I saw described in this decision are regrettably practices that I have seen elsewhere over the course of my time representing tenants, and then more recently from tenants in the Vancouver Tenants Union who have been organizing in buildings,” Stephanie Smith told Global News.
She said the scale of this house is extreme, but there are situations like this across Vancouver.
An inspection of the home in July 2025 found the house near Commercial Drive had been subdivided into 21 rooms with at least 17 tenants, plus multiple bathrooms and plumbing fixtures were added without permits.
That August, the City of Vancouver issued an order to vacate.
“The practice (of) subdividing without permits, making unpermitted renovations, making un-permited changes to electrical and plumbing, egress issues, like all of these life safety issues — these are things that I’ve seen in multiple buildings across the city over decades,” Smith added.
Following an investigation, the Residential Tenancy Branch found the landlords did not maintain the rental property in compliance with health, safety and housing standards required by law and failed to complete urgent plumbing and electrical repairs.
Get weekly money news
They were ordered to pay $85,000 for the first violation and a $5,000 penalty for the second.
The decision showed, however, that the rental home had to the capacity to generate $11,000 a month in revenue for the landlords.
Smith said the $90,000 fine is a large one, but only represents about eight months of income for the property that’s now listed for sale for $1.4 million.
- Alberta tweaks carbon capture incentive program to allow grants during construction
- Nova Scotia marks Transgender Day of Remembrance with flag raising and poetry
- Saskatoon appeals board rules oversized million-dollar home can remain
- ‘Cash is king’: Why money is a popular holiday present for many Canadians
“I have noted and tenant advocates have noted, that the penalties that can be assigned by the RTB (Residential Tenancy Branch) Compliance and Enforcement Unit are not proportional to the harms that can be done to tenants,” Smith said.
“And when you have a larger landlord who may be breaching bylaws or the Residential Tenancy Act in multiple properties, that can amount to a cost of doing business.”
Simon Fraser University’s city program director, Andy Yan, told Global News the dividing of homes in Vancouver reminds him of Hong Kong’s coffin apartments or home — which are essentially wooden boxes with a single bed.
“I think that this is a scene that actually is something out of Vancouver’s past from the 1800s, when they used to just stack people, new and young Canadians, into these places,” Yan said.
Yan added this issue highlights the need for local governments to ensure that landlords are not allowed to do these practices and then pay fines as the cost of doing business.
Get Carney and the Liberals out of Canada
Lower immigration levels back to normal, and housing prices will follow.
Trudeau tripled housing prices due to radically high levels of immigration, forcing undemocratic, fascist population growth, which only benefited the rich.
this is all canadians can afford to pay for rent
Depending on the down payment on the house, $11 000/ month might not cover all the expenses of the house when everything is added up. That kind of rent may be necessary to own a multi million dollar house (not that I condone this kind of housing). To see the whole story of what is going on, the reporter needs to ask more questions not just the sensational ones. A sad set of circumstances all around possibly.
Also the only reference I saw to anything “Asian” was the reference to past Hong Kong box housing yet a few responses seem to point to Asian ownership etc. I have seen a similar set up in the 90s in Burnaby by a Caucasian gentleman who rented a total house, then made rooms up everywhere so he could live free in the house. This kind of practice is not necessarily limited to a certain group of people.
Their assets should be seized and they should be deported. Canada MUST get tough on immigrant criminal activity
Discussions and scrutiny regarding ties to China and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) within the Conservative Party of British Columbia (BC Conservatives) have centered on specific candidates, their past organizational involvement, and internal party fallout:
• Teresa Wat (Richmond-Bridgeport): A former BC Liberal international trade minister who joined the BC Conservatives, Wat faced scrutiny for her historical trade record, which included spearheading a 2016 Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) memorandum of understanding with Guangdong province, promoting RMB-denominated bonds, and facilitating corporate and tech partnerships with Chinese firms. Her background and subsequent clashes within the caucus—including accusations of CCP affiliation by party leadership—led to her departure from the BC Conservative caucus. Read more in the Richmond News Coverage.
• Gordon Zhang (Richmond-Steveston): Zhang, a BC Conservative candidate and business instructor, was scrutinized for co-founding the Grizzly Bear Institute of Canada in 2017—a think tank that engaged Vancouver’s Chinese consulate to promote China’s Belt and Road Initiative and economic/education cooperation. Details of this involvement were initially omitted from his official party biography, drawing public criticism. See the Business in Vancouver Report.
• Caucus Tensions and Allegations: Internal divisions within the BC Conservatives intensified when leadership publicly accused members of CCP ties or influence. For instance, MLA departures occurred after leadership made allegations regarding foreign affiliations, damaging members’ reputations and prompting public fallout.
The coffin apartments in Hong Kong are way nicer.
As if homelessness isn’t sad.
Dumb chinks
Ben you can thank your far left liberal government for inflating house prices so much that this Shack is worth $1.2 million
This isn’t all that unusual. When I was looking at real estate I saw some appalling so-called “student accommodation”. The city needs to do a better job of inspecting.
Burn it down.
The bigger problem is the government’s lack of affordable housing. Likely these tenants will end up living on the streets.
Headline tells you who was running the place. Who else could that be?!?
Look at the names of the owners. Big surprise there. Typical
They have been doing this before Crist was born, no news here
Its all good and fine to blame the homeowners only. Anybody renting knows very well that AFFORDABLE rents are few and far between. Its a simple case of supply and demand. It would seem that as the government does not wish to remedy this problem, people are solving the problem themselves. But oh dear, they did not pay the City thousands of dollars in permits! I am sure this would not be an issue if tenants were complaining about these residences or the safety.
Apparently the landlord is a far left liberal who as only charging a nominal rent of $500 a room he just wanted to give people a roof over their head !!!
What a bleeding heart.