Three scramble crosswalks added nearly five years ago at several of Edmonton’s busiest intersections are being eliminated.
Those who have walked or driven on Whyte Avenue since 2021 would be used to coming across the three pedestrian scrambles at Gateway Boulevard (103 Street), Calgary Trail (104 Street) and 105 Street.
They stop traffic in all directions while allowing pedestrians to cross in any direction — but soon, they will be a thing of the past on 82 Avenue.
Why? The City of Edmonton is implementing new transit priority measures.
The city says the new tools are intended to reduce transit delays and improve services, meaning they prioritize the movement of buses to make mass transit more efficient, reliable, and desirable for Edmontonians.
The city says scramble crosswalks require longer traffic cycles, meaning increased wait times for pedestrians and drivers, eventually affecting traffic flow, transit reliability and emissions.
Some of the proposed measures on Whyte Avenue are between 101 and 107 streets.
At Gateway Boulevard, Calgary Trail and 105 Street, the proposed measures would widen sidewalks, change traffic signal timing with restricted turning movements, and replace scramble crosswalks with the traditional crossings that existed before 2021.
Get daily National news
Pedestrians on Whyte Avenue are mixed on the changes.
“I would be happy if it is changed back because traditional crosswalks are much better, I think. It’s confusing for many people who don’t live in this area; they are stuck walking when they’re not allowed,” said Olena Urvanova.
“I think it’s the same in terms of safety, but in terms of convenience and time saving, my guess that the old one is better.”
Girish Dube says he doesn’t have any issue using scramble crosswalks, and they are similar to ones he’s used in other major cities. He would like them to stay.
“I think when the lights are open on both sides, sometimes we do walk diagonally — that is good, and we support that. But if you close it, then we have to take an ‘L shape’ to wait for that,” said Dube.
The city says traditional crosswalks paired with curb extensions are still safe and accessible for people on the road.
“Curb extensions shorten crossing distances, make pedestrians more visible and encourage drivers to slow down. Turn restrictions reduce conflicts between pedestrians and vehicles. These design elements help keep pedestrians safe while improving bus travel times,” read the city’s website.
The scramble crosswalks on Gateway Boulevard and Calgary Trail were added in the summer of 2021. Drivers at those intersections have, at times, experienced heavy delays — particularly during rush hour.
Natalie Lazurko, the director of transportation planning and design for the City of Edmonton, says it cost the city around $50,000 to install the scramble crosswalks in 2021.
“The total approximate construction cost for the entire TPM project (including the redesign of the three intersections) on Whyte Avenue between 99 Street and 109 Street is $3.3 million,” she said.
“The implementation of transit priority measures on Whyte Avenue reflects the City of Edmonton’s strategic plans and objectives, while continuing to prioritize pedestrian safety by maintaining turning restrictions and implementing safety measures, such as curb extensions. ”
The crosswalk changes are expected to happen later this year, and the city says adjacent businesses will be given advance notice.
eliminate right turn on red all along whyte av.
eliminate right turn in red all along whyte av.
Its about time lol.
Zero Vision
It’s about time. We haven’t construction on whyte ave. for almost a month!
This pandering to pedestrian and bike riding minorities needs to stop. Like Andy said, 85% of working Edmontonians commute by car. Also, adjacent communities such as St. Albert, people either take a bus or drive.
Alberta winter lasts nearly 6 months out of the year, and only the hardcore bike riders (minority compared to drivers) will actually commute by bike… providing the cities do a better job clearing the snow.
About time this council stopped its war on drivers. 85% of working Edmontontonions commute by car. Maybe cater to the majority instead of catering to tiny vocal minorities. Now get rid of the Jasper Ave and 104 Ave scramble intersections as well. You tried it. It was worse. Change it back and move on.
Also a dedicated buslane and removing street parking would do the same thing down Whyte ave but what do I know? I thought we were trying to make Whyte more pedestrian friendly? This is the opposite
No comment on the scribbles down Jasper Ave??
Now do bike lanes
Curb extensions cut down traffic lanes, causing congestion. They also make it much more difficult for larger/longer vehicles to turn.
Why do planners not see the obvious?