Advertisement

B.C. court rules on disputed $2M lottery pool win that ‘ruined relationships’

Click to play video: 'Man’s disputed 6/49 lottery win confirmed by court'
Man’s disputed 6/49 lottery win confirmed by court
A Surrey man is celebrating his 2022 BC/49 lottery win after a court dismissed a claim by his co-workers claiming a share of the $2 million jackpot. Travis Prasad reports – Jan 14, 2025

A B.C. man won’t have to share his $2 million lottery prize, after a B.C. court rejected his coworkers’  claim the payout was a part of their lottery pool.

In a ruling published on Friday, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Y. Liliane Bantourakis concluded that while Mandeep Singh Maan did participate in lottery pools in 2021 and 2022, there was no evidence the winning BC/49 ticket was purchased with group money.

“Winning the lottery should be a happy event. In this case, sadly, it has ruined relationships,” Bantourakis wrote.

Click to play video: 'Bar staff at Vancouver pub win $1M Lotto Max prize'
Bar staff at Vancouver pub win $1M Lotto Max prize

“The plaintiffs went to court with a sincere belief in their entitlement and that’s what the case was fought on,” said lawyer Raman Atwal, who represented the plaintiffs.

Story continues below advertisement

“It came down to the facts,” said Sanjeeta Johal, who represented Maan.

“It came down to the credibility of the parties and whose evidence the court believed. Clearly they preferred my client’s evidence.”

According to the ruling, Mann’s coworkers at a freight and warehousing company claimed they regularly pooled $50 twice a week to buy lottery tickets. Maan, meanwhile, maintained the group only pooled cash for tickets occasionally, usually when there were high jackpots.

The coworkers alleged that between Aug. 12 and Aug. 15, 2022, the group had given Maan cash and a free play ticket from a previous buy, and agreed he’d purchase the next tickets. Maan denied this at trial and claimed he’d bought the ticket with his own money.

For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen.

Get breaking National news

For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

On Aug. 18, Maan discovered the ticket was a winner, but didn’t tell his coworkers. They discovered the win four days later, when the B.C. Lottery Corporation posted a photo of Maan holding the $2 million payout cheque.

In the days to come, the coworkers initially congratulated Maan, but later grew suspicious and claimed they should get a share of the winnings, according to the ruling.

“I didn’t share the news with anybody, so I only know that I share with the wife and I — we decided we just keep it in the family not to celebrate anything,” Maan told Global News.

Story continues below advertisement

“My coworker found out through Facebook, and then they called me. And then. They congratulate. then after a few days or so. They start backing off. And I didn’t know that They’re going to sue me.”

The group filed a lawsuit in September.

Click to play video: 'How to run an office lottery pool'
How to run an office lottery pool

In her ruling, Bantourakis highlighted discrepancies in the coworkers’ story about whether and when Maan was given group funds for the ticket, and found a lack of evidence about a consistent schedule or fixed contribution amount for past lottery ticket buys.

She ruled there was no evidence group money was used to buy the winning ticket, nor were the coworkers able to prove a binding agreement to pool lottery money regularly.

“While I accept that not every group lottery ticket purchase was documented, whether in text messages or photos, the record of photographs that does exist is more consistent with an ad hoc process in which the parties or some of them agreed on a case-by-case basis to buy lottery tickets together,” the judge ruled.

Story continues below advertisement

“It is likely, in my view, that the participants, amount contributed, and frequency of play could vary.”

Click to play video: 'From the archives: Mission A&W employees fight over winning lotto ticket'
From the archives: Mission A&W employees fight over winning lotto ticket

Bantourakis also found the dollar value Maan charged to his debit card for the purchase, $10, was not consistent with the coworkers’ alleged regular $50 pool purchases.

“It is my impression that each of the plaintiffs came to Court with a sincerely held belief in their entitlement to a share of the winnings,” the judge ruled.

“Though the plaintiffs may feel that they have a moral entitlement to a share of the winnings, they have not established any legal entitlement.”

Despite the dispute, Maan is still working at the same company as his coworkers.

The B.C. Lottery Corporation says people who buy group tickets should have written rules and keep good records to prevent this type of dispute.

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices