December 1, 2017 5:27 pm
Updated: December 1, 2017 8:57 pm

Quebec religious neutrality bill suspended by Superior Court judge

WATCH: A Quebec Superior Court judge has suspended Bill 62 at least until guidelines concerning its application are established sometime in 2018. Elysia Bryan-Baynes speaks to one of the lawyer’s involved in the case: Catherine McKenzie.

A A

The province’s religious neutrality law has been suspended by a Quebec Superior Court judge.

READ MORE: Quebec’s religious neutrality bill passes with a vote of 66-51

Section 10 of the Act (personnel members or those receiving services must have their faces uncovered) will be stayed until the final guidelines are published next July.

Story continues below

The court judgement states individuals should be given the opportunity “to seek accommodation on religious grounds” from the law.

READ MORE: Will Quebec stop fighting over religious symbols?

“The applicants plead that a woman who covers her face for religious reasons and who seeks public service will experience violation of her religious freedom and equality. This, they insist, is unconstitutional,” the judgement reads.

In her court declaration, Marie-Michelle Lacoste, a Muslim since 2003 who has been wearing the niqab since 2011, wrote that she “feels concerned about using public services” and “has experienced an increase in personal harassment and insults outside of her home.”

WATCH BELOW: Questions about Bill 62

Nevertheless, the province argued that public interest “must weigh heavily in the balance” and those demanding that the law be suspended have “failed to demonstrate that they have suffered irreparable harm.”

The judgement disputes that, insisting that harm, in this case, cannot be monetarily quantified, or cured.

It states that “the legislature could not have been clearer about its intentions,” saying that the very name of Bill 62 — An Act to foster adherence to state religious neutrality — acknowledges that people may be discriminated against because of the legislation.

WATCH BELOW: Religious neutrality in Quebec

The judgement found that, despite the bill being tabled by Justice Minister Stephanie Vallée in 2015, there has been no rush to include information on how it will handle religious accommodations.

“Religious neutrality, while perhaps a lofty goal, is not time sensitive,” it states.

“Why then bring into force an incomplete state religious neutrality law before July 1, 2018?”

The controversial bill was passed by the National Assembly with a vote of 66-51 last October.

READ MORE: Montrealers cover faces, protest Quebec’s religious neutrality bill

Some estimate there are about 50 women who cover their faces with a niqab or burqa in the province.

Advocates have long said that the bill violates a person’s right to freedom of religion and right to equality in the Quebec Charter and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

rachel.lau@globalnews.ca

© 2017 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error

Comments

Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.