Trump threatened to terminate NAFTA. Canada and Mexico shrugged

Ottawa sees upside in Trump’s threat to rip up NAFTA
WATCH: Turns out U.S. President Donald Trump could be undermining his own plan to get rid of NAFTA. David Akin explains why.

U.S. President Donald Trump threatened, once again, to quit the NAFTA treaty during a rally with supporters in Phoenix, Arizona on Tuesday.

“Personally, I don’t think we can make a deal … I think we’ll end up probably terminating NAFTA at some point,” the president said.

READ MORE: Donald Trump thinks ‘we’ll probably end up terminating NAFTA at some point’

But that statement didn’t seem to rattle Canada’s financial markets. The loonie barely budged in reaction to the comments.

WATCH BELOW: Trudeau says Canada’s focus on NAFTA unchanged in wake of Trump threat

Trudeau says Canada’s focus on NAFTA unchanged in wake of Trump threat
Trudeau says Canada’s focus on NAFTA unchanged in wake of Trump threat

That’s because Trump’s bombastic rhetoric on the trade agreements is starting to sound hollow, experts told Global News.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: Trump asked Ottawa to drop duties on e-commerce under NAFTA. Canadians should cheer, say experts

“People are getting used to Donald Trump and the way in which he bluffs and attempts to shock and awe people with statements like ‘we’ll pull away from NAFTA,'” said Christopher Sands.

In his bestselling book, The Art of the Deal, Trump talks about making unrealistic demands and threatening to walk away from the table as a negotiating tactic meant to shift the talk in one’s favour, Sands noted.

READ MORE: One request by Trump threatens both NAFTA negotiations and the softwood lumber dispute

It’s a device the U.S. president has already deployed several times with NAFTA, but now “people are starting to catch up,” he added.

Mexico’s Foreign Minister Luis Videgaray has already brushed off Trump’s comments as little more than a negotiating tactic on Wednesday.

“He’s negotiating in his own particular style,” Videgaray said, speaking on local television.

Coverage of NAFTA on

Trump might not have the power to unilaterally kill NAFTA

It’s not clear that the U.S. president would be able to unilaterally rescind NAFTA, even he wanted to, noted Carlo Dade, director of the Trade and Investment Centre at Canada West Foundation.

Story continues below advertisement

Congress is responsible for regulating international trade under the U.S. constitution, Dade noted.

“There’s a real constitution question as to whether the president can undo something that Congress has done.”

Many legal scholars believe he can’t, Dade added.

READ MORE: Canada told to explain its oilsands tailings leaks by environmental arm of NAFTA

U.S. presidents may negotiate trade deals, but it is Congress that has the last word and puts legislation into effect to implement the treaties.

Undoing NAFTA would also require undoing all the legislation that was drafted in order to allow the deal to come into force, said Dade.

Of course, Trump could end NAFTA if he got U.S. lawmakers on board, but that, too, seems tricky.

Canada has put in a lot of legwork going to U.S. congressional districts and explaining the importance of NAFTA to the local job market and economy, Dade noted.

READ MORE: NAFTA, Trump and the cloud: What the negotiations mean for your personal data

“People in those congressional districts have started to realize that ‘hey, my job and my neighbour’s job – or a certain per cent of the income in our district – is tied to trade with NAFTA.”

Story continues below advertisement

For that reason, it’s extremely unlikely that Congress would go along with scrapping NAFTA, Dade said.

Trump was likely pandering to his supporters when he made the comments in Phoenix, he added.

It’s something Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has done, too, when his government outlined a push for “progressive” NAFTA chapters on the environment, labour, gender rights and Indigenous relations.

READ MORE: Chrystia Freeland outlines Canada’s objectives in NAFTA negotiations

Those requests likely “won’t have much impact,” said Dade. But they might please Trudeau’s base.

Canada and Mexico have realized the world won’t end, even if NAFTA does

Another likely reason why Canada’s financial markets barely reacted to Trump’s statement is that investors have already priced in the possibility that the trade agreement might end, said Sands.

For Canada, “there would be trouble, but it would be survivable.”

For Mexico, a poorer nation, the consequences would be more serious – not to mention the fact that uncertainty about NAFTA is compounding investor nervousness about the country’s upcoming national election in 2018, said Sands. That may be why the Mexican peso took a hit from Trump’s latest threat, while the loonie didn’t.

Story continues below advertisement

Still, both Canada and Mexico have taken a sober look at what happens if there is no NAFTA and assessed that it wouldn’t be catastrophic, according to Sands.

“They’ve taken the measure of Trump and have decided not to let him push them off the mark.”

READ MORE: How NAFTA could affect the wine industry