August 14, 2017 3:20 pm
Updated: August 14, 2017 8:20 pm

Hate crime in Canada: do our laws allow a white nationalist rally?

Warning: Video contains disturbing content not suitable for all viewers. White nationalists organizers say the rally is to protest the city's decision to remove a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee from Emancipation Park.


Neo-Nazis, skinheads and Ku Klux Klan members all marched in the streets of Charlottesville, Va., over the weekend, protesting the removal of a statue of Confederate general and slavery advocate Robert E. Lee.

Story continues below

The rally turned deadly after a car plowed into a group of people who were protesting the white nationalists. One woman was killed and dozens more were injured.

READ MORE: Charlottesville protest: Who united against the white nationalists?

Although acts of violence are not protected under the First Amendment in the United States (freedom of speech), white nationalist groups are legally allowed to protest as long as there is no “imminent threat”, according to Richard Moon, a law professor at the University of Waterloo.

Even the most hateful and offensive speech is constitutionally protected. But what about in Canada? Could this type of white nationalist rally happen here?

WATCH: A warning that Canadians should not be complacent about the violence surrounding a historic statue in Virginia. It comes from the mayor of Halifax, whose city is wrestling with a monument quandary of its own.

Canada’s hate laws

Canada’s Constitution protects freedom of expression but also honours multiculturalism and equality, Moon said.

Freedom of speech in Canada is not an absolute right and Section 1 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms allows the government to reasonably limit it.

LISTEN:  A University of Ontario professor on the rally in Charlottesville and whether it could happen in Canada

READ MORE: KKK’s new PR spin: we aren’t white supremacists but rather ‘white separatists’

“There are limits on our rights. Our courts have found that if there is a significant harm, freedom of speech has to be restricted,” Moon said.

Unlike the U.S., you can be jailed for promoting hate speech that targets a group, such as handing out a pamphlet with Neo-Nazi literature.

“You cannot distribute any hate that vilifies a particular group,” he said. “So a symbol like a swastika is considered hate speech.”

WATCH: Muslim-Canadian woman on battling misconceptions and Islamophobia 

But there are several conditions that must be met. For example, the hate speech must be the most severe of the genre; must be targeted to an identifiable group (such as a religion, race or sexual orientation); and has to be public.

Under Canada’s Criminal Code, Sections 318, 319, and 320 forbid hate propaganda.

Can this happen in Canada?

There are around 100 white nationalist groups in Canada and more are on the rise, according to Barbara Perry, a University of Ontario Institute of Technology professor who studies hate crimes.

“It seems like there are more chapters that emerged over the past year, like anti-Muslim groups,” she said.

READ MORE: Police investigating after swastikas found in York University classroom

Since the beginning of the year, there have been many cases of swastikas and an anti-Semitic message plastered on university walls, vehicle doors and monuments.

In February, a small group of protesters demonstrated outside a mosque in Toronto carrying signs and banners calling for a ban of Islam. Perry said although their message and signs were hate filled, the demonstrators were not charged under the criminal code.

READ MORE: Hate crimes against Muslims in Canada increase 253% over four years

This is because it’s very difficult to investigate and prosecute hate crimes in Canada. Perry said it happens very rarely.

However, if a large white nationalist rally did happen in Canada, Perry believes it would not look the same as in the U.S.

“It’s more temperate here,” she said. “We have a different history and would probably not see a presence of guns like you do in the States. We also don’t have the same history of racism But we do have racism.”

WATCH: Racist flyers distributed to Richmond homes

© 2017 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error


Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.