July 4, 2017 10:25 am
Updated: July 4, 2017 12:29 pm

Justin Trudeau lobbied at recent fundraising event, critics raise flags about new rules

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau defends his government's appointment process during Question Period in the House of Commons on Tuesday, June 13, 2017.

THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
A A

Among the guests at one of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s recent fundraisers – colloquially referred to as “cash-for-access” events – was a supporter who subsequently received a federal appointment and another man who bought a ticket for the sole purpose of speaking to Trudeau about legislation currently in Parliament.

“I went to that [fundraiser] to try to get Mr. Trudeau’s attention, and I was successful,” said Sherwin Edwards, president of Vap Select, a Quebec company that imports and distributes vaping products.

WATCH: Liberals attacked for ‘cash for access fundraising scheme’


Global News
Help us improve Globalnews.ca
Story continues below

His reason for going to the Montreal event on May 4 was to make sure the prime minister heard his concerns about a Senate bill he says infringes not only on his ability to ensure the success of his six-year-old business but also on the constitutional rights of all Canadians.

The bill, S-5, aims to regulate and restrict promotion of vaping products, and Edwards has organized rallies and demonstrations and led social media campaigns against it.

“Cash for access was the furthest thing from my mind that day. I saw an open door and I walked through it – and I’ll walk through every open door I see,” Edwards, who is not a registered lobbyist, said in a recent interview with Global News.

READ MORE: Legislation to ban private cash-for-access fundraisers to be introduced in Parliament

Also among the guests at the fundraiser that evening at Montreal’s Fine Arts Museum was Jonathan Goldbloom, a Liberal donor who sought the federal nomination for a Montreal-area riding in the last election and was recently appointed to the Via Rail board of directors.

Goldbloom donated more than $18,000 to the federal party, riding associations and to himself as a candidate over the past decade, according to public records with Elections Canada.

WATCH: Ambrose accuses Trudeau of cash-for-access; Trudeau says Liberals follow the rules

In an email to Global News, he confirmed he was at the May 4 fundraiser, but didn’t answer questions asking how much he’d paid for his ticket and whether he discussed the Via position with the prime minister while at the event.

Edwards, the business owner, said he paid $250, the highest donation amount required to attend, according to the Liberal report on the event.

“I took $250 out of my own pocket to accomplish what I needed to accomplish,” he said during a telephone interview from his office in Quebec.

READ MORE: Trudeau to attend public fundraiser as Liberals resume high-profile events

Both scenarios reveal the fundamental problems with this method of fundraising, said Conservative MP John Brassard.

“People are paying to get face time with the prime minister,” he said in a telephone interview from his Ontario riding. “You get preferential treatment with the prime minister if you can pay for it and are OK with your money going into the Liberal coffers.”

Edwards said he saw the $250 price tag as little more than the cost of getting his message on legislation to the prime minister.

WATCH: Conservative MP says Trudeau approached at cash for access fundraiser over sale of BC senior homes

When he saw the prime minister shaking hands with guests, he took position and prepared to share his message.

“When it was my turn, I said, ‘Mr. Trudeau, I want you to know I’m not an activist. I voted for you. But I need you to hear me,’” he recalled.

The prime minister asked Edwards what the issue was, listened to the businessman’s explanation of his issues with Bill S-5, and then told Edwards he should speak to an MP who would act as “his messenger.”

READ MORE: Justin Trudeau admits he gets lobbied at so-called cash-for-access Liberal fundraisers

“I said, ‘Why? You can’t talk about it?’ and he said, ‘No,’” Edwards said. “The next day it came to me; he was taking heat for these fundraisers.”

Global News asked the prime minister’s staff what to make of the fact a person can still pay to bend Trudeau’s ear on active legislation, or the optics of someone paying to attend an event with Trudeau weeks before receiving a federal appointment.

READ MORE: Trudeau recuses himself from choice of ethics watchdog in wake of Aga Khan trip

Trudeau’s spokesperson directed the question to the party.

“The event you reference was attended by over 200 people,” Liberal party spokesperson Braeden Caley said, also noting the party has nothing to do with any federal appointments.

“Justin Trudeau meets thousands of Canadians each month, and it won’t come as a surprise that Liberal supporters attend events with the leader of the Liberal party as well.”

WATCH: Ambrose compares Trudeau Liberal fundraising to Ontario bribery scandal

Caley didn’t answer a question posed about whether the fact an individual can go into such events with the sole purpose of lobbying the prime minister is a symptom of any problems with this nature of fundraising.

Earlier this year, the Liberals brought in a months-long moratorium on fundraising events featuring Trudeau and other ministers, in the wake of accusations they were providing preferential access in exchange for dollars from wealthy donors.

The events in question were often held at private residences or firms and required payments up to $1,500.

In the ensuing months, the party worked to develop new rules around the practice in an effort to increase transparency around their fundraising.

WATCH: Liberals announce changes to party fundraising rules, security

The new system, of which the Montreal event was a part, involves holding fundraisers featuring Trudeau or ministers only in public places, announcing them in advance, allowing media to attend and disclosing the guest list within the following 45 days.

Neither opposition party has adopted equivalent methods of publicizing fundraising, which the Liberal party trumpets these changes as steps toward increased transparency.

Still, the Conservative critic said it does little save for legitimizing and formalizing “cash-for-access” fundraisers.

“They’re bringing it out of the shadows, but [the new rules] haven’t changed the fact that people can pay to bend the prime minister’s ear … it’s a greasy way of fundraising,” Brassard said.

— With a file from The Canadian Press

© 2017 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error

Comments

Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.