Will Airbnb’s impact on the short-term rental market be its downfall?

Airbnb is facing challenges all over the world thanks to its impact on the short-term rental market. Michael Hurcomb/Variety/REX/Shutterstock

Could Airbnb’s impact on the short-term rental market be its downfall?

Airbnb, the online lodging service that investors now believe is worth $30 billion, faces a reckoning.

In eight years of torrid growth, the company has often clashed with local public officials seeking to minimize the impact of short-term rentals on neighborhoods and urban housing markets. Now, those simmering tensions are starting to boil.

READ MORE: Doubts raised over Quebec’s legislation regulating Airbnb-type rentals

The New York state legislature has passed regulations that Airbnb says could seriously damage its business in New York City, the company’s largest U.S. market; Governor Andrew Cuomo has until Oct. 29 to decide whether it will become law. The German capital of Berlin recently passed a law banning most short-term rentals, and Barcelona and Amsterdam are imposing steep fines for listings that violate laws there.

Story continues below advertisement

WATCH: Airbnb under fire for offering $250 bonus in Vancouver’s tight renal market

Click to play video 'Airbnb under fire for offering $250 bonus in Vancouver’s tight rental market' Airbnb under fire for offering $250 bonus in Vancouver’s tight rental market
Airbnb under fire for offering $250 bonus in Vancouver’s tight rental market – Aug 26, 2016

Ground zero for Airbnb’s fight against tightening regulations is its home of San Francisco, where the company has sued to block a new requirement that it reject booking fees from property owners who have not registered with the city.

The case is a crucial test of Airbnb’s business model. The company argues it cannot legally be held responsible for how landlords use its platform. If it is required to enforce local laws on short-term rentals, that could drastically reduce listings – and revenue – in some of its biggest markets.

READ MORE: San Francisco woman says her house was trashed by an Airbnb renter filming porn

Click to play video 'Woman listing room on Airbnb says guest ran an ‘adult’ business' Woman listing room on Airbnb says guest ran an ‘adult’ business
Woman listing room on Airbnb says guest ran an ‘adult’ business – Aug 9, 2016

Other cities looking to rein in Airbnb are watching the proceedings and looking to the city’s law as a potential model, said James Emery, deputy city attorney of San Francisco.

Story continues below advertisement

“Throughout the country, people representing cities have called me to ask what’s going on with the litigation,” he said.

Airbnb’s legal argument relies on a 20-year-old statute designed to protect free speech online, known as Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. The company asserts in its lawsuit that San Francisco “impermissibly treats Airbnb as the publisher or speaker of third-party content” when it is merely a platform for communications between property owners and guests.

READ MORE: Airbnb introduces a broader insurance coverage policy for Canadians

Other online marketplaces – such as Amazon, eBay , and Craigslist – have cited the same law to shield themselves from liability for any improper transactions among users of their services.

In the San Francisco case, U.S. District Judge James Donato said at an Oct. 6 hearing he wasn’t “seeing the link” between free speech protections and San Francisco’s short-term rental regulations. Donato is expected to issue a ruling soon.

Airbnb has also sued the Southern California city of Anaheim, home to the Disneyland theme park, and the nearby beach city of Santa Monica, over regulations that the company contends are illegal.

“Illegal” business model

Airbnb takes a cut of the revenue when a room or a home is booked and charges a service fee to guests. The company says it helps communities by enabling middle-class families to make extra money.

Story continues below advertisement

It also points to agreements with officials in nearly 200 locales around the world, mostly for tax collection and in some cases for broader short-term rental regulation.

READ MORE: Damages could hit $150,000 in Calgary home trashed by Airbnb renters

Critics counter that, in popular tourist destinations, Airbnb takes affordable housing off the market, drives up home prices and disrupts neighborhoods with streams of transient visitors.

As regulatory threats loom, Airbnb on Wednesday announced it would create an online registration system for property owners and automate the enforcement of Airbnb’s existing rules in New York and San Francisco, which limit operators to a single listing of an entire residence.


New York Assemblywoman Linda Rosenthal, sponsor of the New York legislation, was unimpressed by Airbnb’s announcement.

“It’s preposterous. Maybe half their listings are illegal” in New York City, she said. “It’s part-and-parcel of the business model.”

READ MORE: Noirebnb and Noirbnb – two startups that want to solve Airbnb’s alleged racism problem

Existing New York state law bars most urban apartment-dwellers from renting out their units for less than 30 days if they are not present.


Story continues below advertisement

The law recently passed by the state legislature would bar even advertising a rental that violates that existing law, which could help regulators crack down on Airbnb itself in addition to the users of its service.

Airbnb has said it will sue New York state if the governor enacts the law. The company said it has taken down nearly 3,000 illegal listings in New York City over the past year, and reports 44,622 total listings in the city as of Sept. 1.

WATCH: What is Airbnb’s effect on Vancouver’s rental market

Click to play video '‘Airbnb’ and its effects on Vancouver’s limited rental market' ‘Airbnb’ and its effects on Vancouver’s limited rental market
‘Airbnb’ and its effects on Vancouver’s limited rental market – Jul 18, 2016

The company also ran into problems in Vancouver this summer, after offering would-be hosts a $250 incentive to attract new hosts in the city. However, because Vancouver’s rental vacancy rate remains critically low, the promotion sparked anger among local councillors.

READ MORE: Airbnb financial incentive angers Vancouver councillor George Affleck

Vancouver bylaws prohibit most short-term rentals.

Story continues below advertisement

“Airbnb is a part of the problem, certainly, that people are not renting their units for long term and that’s having an impact,” said councillor George Affleck.

In July, Airbnb issued a report that pushed back against concerns it’s having a negative impact on rental vacancies in Vancouver.

Vancouver is studying the impact of Airbnb and similar websites on rental housing. Staff will report to council in September with suggestions on how to regulate the service.

Battle in Berlin

In Berlin, Airbnb is fighting a city demand that it turn over information to help enforce a new law imposing fines of up $110,000 on people renting out more than 50 percent of their homes for less than two months – among the strictest regulations worldwide.

Airbnb is “confident it would find a favorable agreement” with the city,” said Peter Huntingford, Airbnb head of public affairs for Europe.

READ MORE: Airbnb’s alleged racism problem continues – North Carolina host removed following racist rant

But with the city intent on collecting data and Airbnb intent on refusing, another legal battle looms.

“If Airbnb intends to risk a trial, we are prepared to walk down that path,” said Martin Pallgen, a Berlin Senate spokesman.

Story continues below advertisement

In Barcelona, Airbnb’s third-largest market in Europe, the city is imposing fines that exceed $65,000 for listings without proper licenses. Amsterdam city officials in April started scraping data from Airbnb and other short-term rental websites to root out illegal hosts because Airbnb will not turn over details on violators.

READ MORE: Black Airbnb users speak out about ‘widespread discrimination’ on service

In its Wednesday announcement, Airbnb put forward what the company’s head of global policy and public affairs, Chris Lehane, called a “comprehensive regulatory strategy” targeted at “rooting out bad actors.”

But the new proposals stopped short of any commitments to share information or enforce bans on short-term rental operators, which many cities say is crucial for effective regulation.

Risking Risks

Critics contend that a large portion of Airbnb listings are offered by commercial operators with multiple properties who are essentially running illegal hotels. The company, they argue, has effectively turned many residential neighborhoods into tourist zones.

In Los Angeles, a study by the pro-labor Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy found that property owners with two or more listings generated 44 percent of all Airbnb revenue in Los Angeles.

WATCH: Maple Leafs legend Wendel Clark lists cottage on Aibnb

Click to play video 'Maple Leafs legend Wendel Clark lists Muskoka cottage on Airbnb' Maple Leafs legend Wendel Clark lists Muskoka cottage on Airbnb
Maple Leafs legend Wendel Clark lists Muskoka cottage on Airbnb – May 18, 2016

Airbnb, in a statement, disputed that conclusion and called the group’s analysis “misleading.”

Story continues below advertisement

In New York City, the state Attorney General found that, between 2010 and 2014, more than 300,000 Airbnb reservations violated the law, representing about $304 million in booking revenue, with about $40 million of that going to Airbnb.

Public officials need to prioritize the rights of full-time residents over landlords and visitors, said Rosenthal, the New York Assemblywoman.

“I represent New Yorkers,” she said. “I don’t represent tourists, and my responsibility is not to protect their cheap deal at the expense of New Yorkers.” (Reporting by Heather Somerville in San Fancisco and Tina Bellon in Berlin. Additional reporting by Dan Levine.; Editing by Jonathan Weber and Brian Thevenot)