Man found guilty of stabbing his mother to death in Toronto’s PATH system

A jury has found a man guilty of first-degree murder in the stabbing death of his 51-year-old mother in Toronto’s PATH system more than two years ago.

Twenty-one-year-old Duncan Sinclair was convicted Friday in the killing of Rae Cara Carrington at her workplace.

On April 10, 2019, Sinclair went to Fast Fresh Foods in the PATH system armed with a knife and stabbed Carrington multiple times.

She died at the scene.

At issue for the jury in the trial was the identity of the man seen on surveillance video at the restaurant at the time of the stabbing, as well as motive.

For a person to be convicted of first-degree murder, in most cases the killer must have shown premeditation.

The jury was shown video which captured the suspect pacing back and forth outside the restaurant for 14 minutes before he eventually walked in, spoke to Carrington, pulled out a large knife, chased her through the prep area, and stabbed her multiple times.

Four people had identified Sinclair as being the suspect captured on video.

The Crown offered the theory that the attack was premeditated based on calls Sinclair made to different franchises attempting to find out the location his mother worked at.

The Crown also suggested that Sinclair had sided with his father in a domestic feud. At the time of Carrington’s death, Sinclair’s father was in custody “as a result of domestic and child abuse spanning over 30 years against Rae and the couple’s eight children.”

Two days after the killing, Sinclair, then 19, was arrested after an employee at the YMCA Employment Centre in Midland, Ont., noticed the man who had given the name “Daniel Williams” was searching a murder investigation in Toronto online.

1:56 21-year-old man on trial for 1st-degree murder of his mother

• 21-year-old man on trial for 1st-degree murder of his mother
• Suspect in PATH stabbing makes first court appearance
• Police arrest 19 year old man in connection to fatal PATH stabbing
• Police charge 19-year-old Toronto man in connection to fatal PATH stabbing
• Memorial forms for woman fatally stabbed in Toronto’s PATH system
• Toronto police identify woman killed in PATH stabbing
• Woman dead after stabbing in underground PATH system
• Toronto police provide details of stabbing in downtown underground PATH system

Previous Video

Next Video