Trudeau says U.S. putting troops near Canadian border would be a ‘mistake’

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said Friday it would be a mistake for the United States to position troops near the Canadian border.

And Trudeau said he has made that clear to the Trump administration, as Ottawa seeks clarity from Washington on any American possible plans to deploy its military.

“We have expressed to the United States that it would be a mistake to position troops near the Canadian border, and we certainly hope that they’re not going to go through with that,” the prime minister said Friday during his daily televised briefing from his Rideau Cottage residence.

The prime minister said when he knows more, he’ll share the information with Canadians.

“We continue to engage closely in back and forths with the American administration on many, many issues around the border, and when we have more information, we’ll share it,” said Trudeau.

1:07 Coronavirus outbreak: Trump confirms troops along U.S./ Canada border, calls it ‘equal justice’

Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland was also forceful in denouncing the idea.

“Canada has continued to express clearly and forcefully its view that there is no logical reason to militarize our border with the United States and we have been very clear also that such an action would damage our relationship,” she said Friday.

Ottawa was still scrambling to react to the U.S. proposal, which appeared aimed at bolstering the work of its own domestic border service. But the potential scope or extent of any U.S. plan to deploy its military along the world’s longest undefended border remained, at least as of midday Friday, unexplained.

The two countries already have a mutual ban in place on non-essential travel, but the movement of trade, commerce and cross-border workers has been allowed to continue.

But U.S. President Donald Trump added to the confusion in remarks at the White House late Thursday afternoon, when he said — without any explanation — that the U.S. already has troops “along the border” with Canada.

Get breaking National news

For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen.

Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up

By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Trump then went on a riff about one of his favourite topics — tariffs — and restated old concerns about cheap Chinese steel coming into the U.S. market from Canada.

0:43 Coronavirus outbreak: Pelosi signs landmark coronavirus stimulus bill, sending it to Trump

“You know, we have a lot of things coming in from Canada. We have trade _ some illegal trade that we don’t like. We have very strong sanctions on some. We have very strong tariffs on dumping steel. And we don’t like steel coming through our border that’s been dumped in Canada so they can avoid the tariff,” said Trump.

Canada and Mexico have resolved a major standoff with the Trump administration after it imposed punitive tariffs on their steel and aluminum exports to the U.S. The U.S. had concerns about countries such as China using Canada and Mexico as a conduit to dump cheap steel into the American market. Canada and Mexico are now closely monitoring their foreign metals imports to avoid that from happening — and to prevent the U.S. from reinstating tariffs.

“You know, I charge a lot of tariff for the steel. And it’s been great for our steel companies because now they can really go — you look at what’s happened with steel. It’s been pretty incredible. But we’ve taken in billions and billions of dollars in tariffs on steel, and much of it comes in from China, but they can come through the Canadian border, too. So we’re always watching for that,” said Trump.

2:49 Trump looking to put troops near Canada-U.S. border

Earlier Thursday, Freeland said Canada had argued “forcefully” against the idea, although she was reluctant to characterize the status of the proposal, first reported by Global News, beyond saying a U.S. decision “has not yet been acted upon or fully taken.”

She also noted countries around the world, including Canada, have been responding with uncharacteristic speed and urgency to an escalating global emergency, which involves discussing any and all measures, no matter how drastic, even if they don’t come to fruition.

The current, mutual ban on non-essential travel by Canada and the U.S. reflects that the countries realize the economic importance of avoiding a complete shutdown at the border. For Canada, keeping trade moving is essential — the U.S. is its largest trading partner, as the economies of the two countries are deeply intertwined.

Trudeau reiterated Friday in Ottawa that Canada and the U.S. have the longest unmilitarized border in the world and it is in the interests of both countries to keep it that way.

It is no secret, however, Trump has long been seized with securing his country’s southern border with Mexico, and has recently been talking about fortifying those efforts under the pretence of protecting Americans from the novel coronavirus.

Trump has also made it clear that in an election year, he is chafing for a return to some form of economic normalcy, and sooner rather than later — the April 12 Easter weekend is his hoped-for timeline, a date that has left public-health officials incredulous.

2:27 Coronavirus outbreak: Freeland calls deployment of troops at Canada / U.S. border ‘entirely unnecessary’

Meanwhile, Freeland said Friday she is in other “urgent” discussions with U.S. officials over reports that American border agents could deport asylum seekers on the Canada-U.S. border turned back by Canada under the new border agreement between the two countries.

Trudeau announced last week anyone crossing between the two countries on foot to claim asylum will be turned away as part of the broader deal to close the border to all but non-essential traffic, and American officials now say these migrants will be returned to their country of origin.

Freeland noted that Canada has international obligations when it comes to refugees, including commitments to “non-refoulement,” which means not placing refugees at risk of deportation to countries where they face risk of torture or persecution.

“We are aware of the problems of refoulement and it was, and continues to be, important for Canada to have assurances that that would not happen to people returned to the United States,” Freeland said Friday.

“This is an issue which we are urgently discussing now … it is important for us to abide by our international commitments when it comes to refugees and we are very alive to concerns around refoulement.”