Support for medically assisted dying high in Atlantic Canada: survey

Kathleen Finlay / Getting Images

A Maritime research firm says three quarters of people polled are in favour of allowing medical assistance as an end-of-life option.

According to the Government of Canada, a total of 6,749 Canadians have made requests since federal legislation was passed in June 2016 allowing eligible Canadians to request assistance in dying (MAID).

According to the Canadian government website, in Atlantic Canada last year, from Jan. 1 to Oct. 31, 2018, 195 people requested assistance in dying, with the most reported underlying medical condition being cancer-related.

READ MORE: 40-year-old Paralympic champ dies by euthanasia after years of spinal disease pain

Narrative Search, a Halifax-based market research company, included a number of questions on the issue in their telephone survey, from July 31 to Aug. 25, to find out how many Atlantic Canadians support MAID and the legislation.

Story continues below advertisement

“Every single quarter we reach out and talk to Atlantic Canadians about issues, and this was just a topic that we asked about,” said Margaret Brigley, CEO of Narrative Research.

She added that this report was not commissioned by anyone. “We literally pick topics that seem to be of particular relevance. So at that point in time, when the survey was going into field, there was a lot of public discussion going on [about MAID].”

Finding support across Atlantic Canada for MAID

Based on a telephone sample of 1,500 adults, they found that three quarters (77 per cent) of Atlantic Canadians support medically assisted dying.

While support for MAID is high across Atlantic Canada, residents in P.E.I. (70 per cent) are somewhat less likely to support the law allowing medically-assisted dying.

READ MORE: Scott Thompson: In death, Audrey Parker issues a challenge to Canadian leaders

In New Brunswick the support is at 77 per cent, in Nova Scotia at 77 per cent and in Newfoundland the support is at 80 per cent.

Story continues below advertisement

Across the population, higher income earners, those under the age of 55 years, and those with higher education levels are most likely to support medically-assisted dying.

Easing restrictions

According to Narrative Search, three quarters of Atlantic Canadians also support easing restrictions for those with advanced Alzheimer’s and dementia.

In 2018, as reported by Global News, a terminally ill Halifax woman ended her life with medical assistance – but not before issuing a deathbed plea to federal lawmakers.

READ MORE: Halifax woman’s fight to change Canada’s assisted-dying law continues after her death

Audrey Parker said she wanted Ottawa to drop a provision that says anyone approved for a medically assisted death must be conscious and mentally sound at the moment they give their final consent for a lethal injection.

Parker, who was suffering from a Stage 4 breast cancer diagnoses, said it forced her to choose to die sooner than she would have liked.

Click to play video 'A look at the roadblocks faced by some Albertans seeking medical assistance in dying' A look at the roadblocks faced by some Albertans seeking medical assistance in dying
A look at the roadblocks faced by some Albertans seeking medical assistance in dying

The same provision that Parker issued a plea against is also applicable to people living with dementia, but the way it’s experienced can be very different because unlike certain types of cancer, dementia is a brain disease that can cause cognitive impairment.

Story continues below advertisement

Under the current law, according to Alzheimer Nova Scotia, a person with advanced stages of dementia will likely not be able to legally consent to MAID given the requirement for applicants to be capable of retaining and understanding new information, analyzing the information and making an informed decision.

‘MAID is very complex’

The advanced effects of dementia in its advanced state may impair a person’s capacity to make an informed decision about their end-of-life care, so if a person loses capacity they can no longer access MAID.

In light of this, the people that were interviewed for the survey were asked if they ‘completely support’, ‘mostly support’, ‘mostly oppose’, or ‘completely oppose’ changing the law to allow those with Alzheimer’s and dementia to have the option to make an early request for an assisted death.

More than 70 per cent of people voted completely and mostly support in New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland. But in P.E.I., support was again lower at 62 per cent.

READ MORE: NSHA quietly changes medically assisted dying policy at Catholic hospital

The CEO of the Alzheimer Society of Canada, Pauline Tardiff, says “MAID is very complex.”

She said the society is there to support Canadians living with dementia and caregivers through the process of making their end of life decisions, including MAID if that’s what they want.

Story continues below advertisement

‘It’s difficult to predict future suffering’

The society is also an advocate for improved quality palliative care that is adequately resourced and available to all people with dementia as they near the end of their life.

“Until someone loses capacity, they can request MAID, including if they presently live with dementia. That is possible,” Tardiff said.

But Tardiff explains that with dementia a person may not be suffering immediately until mid or advanced stages and at that point the individual loses their ability to consent.

READ MORE: St. Martha’s Hospital remains firm on policy against medically assisted dying

At the moment MAID is administered, the individual also needs to reconfirm their intent to go through the process, and needs to do so with full understanding.

“It’s difficult to predict future suffering over time, and also that a person’s wishes may change over time. Those are two pieces that are not mentioned in [the report], but are very important to consider,” she said.
Story continues below advertisement
Click to play video 'Ask The Doctor: World Alzheimer’s Month' Ask The Doctor: World Alzheimer’s Month
Ask The Doctor: World Alzheimer’s Month

Tardiff said sometimes the person with dementia is quite happy in their state, and don’t know that they have dementia. As a result, the person is not necessarily able to logically think through their current or future pain and suffering.

‘How do we want to die?’

“In our experiences supporting people living with dementia, it’s not that everybody wants access to MAID. But they do want to have the choice around their end of life care and death,” she said.

“MAID is bringing to the fore the discussion around how do we want to die? So that’s a good thing, in a sense, because in our culture, we’re not talking about end of life,” Tradiff said. “I would also say that our statement honors the challenges of decisions or understands the challenges of decisions for end of life care. They are very complex and we’re not having enough of them.”

Story continues below advertisement

According to a statement released by the Alzheimer Society in Oct. 2019, it’s important for people living with dementia to make their wishes known to their family members while they are still capable of doing so.

READ MORE: Toronto woman raising awareness about medical assistance in dying days before she plans to end her life

“The prevalence of dementia and Alzheimer’s is increasing in Canada, with incidence increasing with age. Here in Atlantic Canada, we have the highest proportion of seniors in the country,” said Brigley.

Click to play video 'Alzheimer Society of New Brunswick opens new office in Fredericton' Alzheimer Society of New Brunswick opens new office in Fredericton
Alzheimer Society of New Brunswick opens new office in Fredericton

According to the Alzheimer Society, there are currently 17,000 Nova Scotians living with dementia, and over half a million across Canada.

“Given the diseases’ particular relevance for our population, it’s not surprising that public support for a change in legislation to ease restrictions for those with advanced Alzheimer’s and dementia is strong,” Brigley added.

Story continues below advertisement

Four in ten ‘completely support’ such a change, according to Narrative Search.