Advertisement

Mustard on pizza? NYC restaurant’s new topping a hit (and miss)

A restaurant in New York City serves pizza with mustard instead of tomato sauce. Would you try it?. Getty Images

Forget the great pineapple-on-pizza debate, we’ve now moved into condiment territory. The latest proposed topping? Mustard.

A recent tweet by Food Insider has left people both curious and confused — according to the blog, there’s a restaurant in New York City that puts mustard on their pizza.

Yes, instead of sticking to a traditional tomato-based or white sauce, Lions & Tigers & Squares Detroit Pizza has opted for something a lot more yellow.

READ MORE: Reality check — Is pizza a healthier breakfast choice than cereal?

Known as Detroit-style pizza (square-shaped, brick cheese and thick crusted), one of the restaurant’s partners Francis Garcia said he first got the idea for mustard-based pizza after picking up some Detroit-style pizza pans and trying the pizza in New Jersey.

Story continues below advertisement
“Mustard pizza is actually a Trenton, New Jersey thing,” he said in a video for Food Insider. “It was born in a place called Papa’s Tomato Pies. A guy came in there, he was drunk [and] he was slurring and he was trying to order a mushroom pie.”

Garcia explained the storeowner at that time said, “Mustard pie? Give it to him!”

Breaking news from Canada and around the world sent to your email, as it happens.

“They put the mustard on the pie with the tomato sauce and it was a hit.”

READ MORE: ‘Hangry’ woman calls police because pizza is late

Starting with a base of dough and mustard, pizzas are usually topped with corned beef, sauerkraut and cheese — basically a glorified sandwich.

Story continues below advertisement

View this post on Instagram

#Repost @nycbestpizza ・・・ I have very rarely stumbled across this being done, certainly this is my first time seeing it in New York City: #mustardpizza. 🍕 I know. It sounds crazy. But I’m a fan. As far as I can tell, and as I said a few weeks ago, mustard pizza was, if not invented at @papastomatopies invented nearby by a pizzeria since closed. Papa’s picked up the tradition… and voila. 🍕 Here in Manhattan, it’s being done with #guldensmustard and extra cheese in Chelsea by @lionsandtigersandsquares. I’ve yet to hear the elaboration on the inspiration but am dying to hear how this came about. Mustard Detroit-style pizza is some kinda crazy Jersey-Michigan hybrid I have to wrap my head around. Unless… that is, this is also a Detroit thing I just don’t know about 😂 (Detroit pizza experts, weigh in please.) 🍕 How is it? Friends and colleagues compared it to feeling like you’re eating a hot dog but without the hot dog. That’s a familiar refrain. When @nytimes wrote about it at Papa’s years ago, that’s pretty much what they said. 🍕 I dig it. And everyone I offered a taste to loved it too. Or at least they told me they did and I said I had no horse in the game. 🍕 My only note here is that at Papa’s they brush the dough with mustard and then add sauce. I really dig the mustard-tomato sauce combo… the acidity becomes much more nuanced and fun. 🍕 Asked the manager if he’d do it that way for me next time and he said sure… so expect a follow-up post. — #pizzacowboy🍕🤠 #nycbestpizza #bestpizzanyc 🍕 #detroit #detroitpizza #nylovesdetroitpizza #chelseapizza #chelseanyc #lunchpizza #sliceofheaven #pizza #eeeeeats #pizzafordays #pizzaislife #lionsandtigersandbearsohmy #lionsandtigersandsquares #lionsandtigersandsquaresohmy ================================== #pizzalovers #pizzas #pizza🍕 #ilovepizza #pizzalover #pizzaparty #pizzapics #pizzagram #pizzatime #detroitpizza #detroitstylepizza

A post shared by Lions&tigers&squares (@lionsandtigersandsquares) on

On Twitter, many people had opinions on putting mustard on their pizza.

READ MORE: Montreal’s ‘pizza war’ appears headed for court battle

Would you try mustard pizza? Let us know in the comments below.

arti.patel@globalnews.ca
Story continues below advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices