As NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) negotiations continue, experts agree that the U.S. proposals put forth on the North American auto industry pose significant difficulties for Canada and Mexico.
On Friday, Oct. 13, the U.S. NAFTA negotiation team presented its proposed changes to the auto sector. These involve boosting the North American content requirements in all vehicles from 62.5 per cent to 85 per cent as well as implementing a “Made in America” content requirement of 50 per cent.
-
![]()
Trudeau, Mexico pushing for ‘gender chapter’ in NAFTA deal -
![]()
Abandoning NAFTA could mean economic chaos for North America: Neal -
![]()
Canada, Mexico say ‘poison pill’ threat by U.S. won’t add extra pressure to NAFTA talks -
![]()
Trudeau says Canada will counter U.S.’s aggressive NAFTA proposal -
![]()
Trudeau wants NAFTA renegotiation to be a ‘win-win-win’ agreement -
![]()
Trudeau heads to Mexico for NAFTA negotiations -
![]()
Trudeau meets Trump in D.C. hoping to save NAFTA -
![]()
Donald Trump calls NAFTA horrendous, one sided -
![]()
Canada’s top priorities in NAFTA negotiations
Failure to meet these requirements would force corporations to pay a U.S. tariff of around 2.5 per cent. The changes would apply to trucks, automobiles and large vehicle parts.
Mexico’s deputy economy minister, Juan Carlos Baker, said at the halfway point of negotiations “there’s no question there’s some difficult proposals.” While he said Mexico would consider all of them, he states “it’s clear to us that there are certain things that are proposals that go against the country’s objectives.” Canadian negotiators have yet to formally comment on that motion.
-
![]()
Canada’s top priorities in NAFTA negotiations -
![]()
Trudeau tries to explain what clarity he got from Trump on NAFTA -
![]()
Trudeau praises ‘good faith’ meeting with Trump on NAFTA talks -
![]()
Harper pessimistic Trump will be able to shepherd NAFTA deal -
![]()
Trump on NAFTA talks: It’s possible ‘fair’ deal can’t be done -
![]()
Trudeau arrives at White House to meet with Trump as NAFTA talks loom -
![]()
Trudeau heads to Washington for NAFTA negotiations -
![]()
Trump jokes about NAFTA negotiations with Pittsburgh Penguins owner during team visit
Tony Faria, co-director of the Office of Automotive and Vehicle Research at the University of Windsor, believes that if these proposals are not walked back, they are virtually unacceptable.
Faria explained in an interview that these content requirements would have an adverse effect on the Canadian auto sector whether companies attempt to meet them, or simply decide to swallow the costs of the 2.5 per cent tariff.
“Those numbers would never be acceptable…we’d end up with pretty much nothing coming from Canada.”
While he hopes that the three nations are able come to an agreement, he doesn’t believe it’s possible if the Trump administration doesn’t come down on their proposed content restrictions.
Carleton University international affairs professor went a step further to say these proposals are “bordering on ridiculous.” He explains that the auto sector would suffer greatly in Canada if vehicle manufacturers were to attempt to meet those requirements.
Experts are also in agreement that if these content requirements were to be implemented, employment in Canada’s auto sector would also suffer as a result.
Unifor president Jerry Dias, the largest union representing auto workers in Canada, says that if taken at face value, content requirements like this could barrage Canada’s auto and steel industries.
-
![]()
President Trump hopes Penguins owner will help him re-negotiate NAFTA -
![]()
Trudeau to meet with Trump about NAFTA negotiations -
![]()
A NAFTA deal by end of year is possible: Jacome -
![]()
Government does not make ideological disputes at NAFTA table: Freeland -
![]()
‘No surprise’ Americans approach NAFTA talks with American-first agenda: Freeland -
![]()
Freeland praises five days of ‘productive’ NAFTA talks -
![]()
Freeland quotes Ronald Reagan as NAFTA talks continue in Ottawa -
![]()
Bell Canada wants NAFTA deal to crackdown on piracy sites
While he doesn’t think the proposal will hold up with the other countries at the negotiating table, Dias said that if content requirements become too difficult to meet, they may decide to save time and money by producing the vast majority of vehicle parts inside the United States.
He calls the potential effects of that move on auto Canadian manufacturing “devastating.”
-
![]()
NDP urge Liberals to ‘stand up’ for labour standards in NAFTA -
![]()
NAFTA negotiations drag on -
![]()
Freeland ‘optimistic’ over possible labour chapter improvements in NAFTA talks -
![]()
Freeland says proposals for ‘contentious’ NAFTA issues not received yet from U.S. -
![]()
Issues dealt with in current NAFTA talks the ‘bread and butter’ for Canada business people: Freeland -
![]()
Canada making ‘solid progress’ in NAFTA negotiations: Freeland -
![]()
NDP urge for labour provisions, auto policies in NAFTA negotiations -
![]()
NAFTA negotiations: Conservatives call on Liberals to make auto industry a priority in talks -
![]()
Chrystia Freeland remains tight-lipped while pressed on NAFTA talks -
![]()
NAFTA negotiations polling
Erin O’Toole, Conservative federal MP for the Durham region, has been an outspoken critic of the way the auto industry has been handled in NAFTA negotiations thus far. Global News also reached out to the Liberal Party of Canada but did not receive a comment.
“You can come into a negotiation taking very strong, aggressive positions,” O’Toole explained. O’Toole called the content requirements “virtually unacceptable as is,” but he believes it’s in the best interest of Canadian and American industries to work towards a middle ground before the end-of-year negotiation deadline.
“We still have time to drive towards a consensus.”
Comments