November 25, 2016 7:11 pm

Canadian investigated in Germany for suspected hate speech

WATCH: A Canadian has had his computer and notes seized by German Police. As Christina Stevens reports, the man is a holocaust denier – a crime in Germany.

A A

“Hello, I’m Alfred Schaefer,” is the simple introduction at the beginning of the video.

It doesn’t take long however, before the hate becomes evident.

“The Jews wanted to exterminate the German people,” is a fairly typical statement from Schaefer’s videos.

READ MORE: Ontario teen who called for ‘white’ Canada has laptop seized by CBSA

Story continues below

Schaefer denies the holocaust, which is something he could do safely in Canada, where he grew up. In Germany, where Schaefer now lives, holocaust denial is illegal.

“The German ministry of forbidden thoughts sent the kriminalpolizei, which is like the FBI, to raid our house in order to steal all of my computers and storage devices,” Schaefer described the police investigation.

“They suspected forbidden thoughts on these devices.”

READ MORE: Formal hate crimes complaints filed with police over GTA teen YouTuber

B’nai Brith Canada’s National Director said calls to their hate hot line alerted them to Schaefer’s videos a few months ago.

“When we became aware, we went to our contacts, and made the German authorities away of it,” said Amanda Hohman.

Canada’s hate speech laws are weaker than some other jurisdictions.

Another Canadian’s racist videos can be viewed in Canada but have been blocked from Youtube in close to two dozen countries.

READ MORE: GTA teen posting neo-Nazi videos is being manipulated by hate groups: expert

Still, Hohman said the real issue is a lack of enforcement of the laws that Canada does have.

“They are really, rarely enforced and charges are really, rarely laid and then when charges are laid, it is almost impossible to get a conviction,” said Hohman.

Over the past five years in Ontario, there have been 17 charges laid under incitement or promotion of hatred laws, according to the Ministry of the Attorney General.

READ MORE: Few hate speech charges laid in Ontario, despite rise in hate speech online: experts

Of those, there has been just one conviction. Another is going to trial and the rest have been dismissed by the court or withdrawn.

Hohman said law enforcement has to do more, as words lead to action.

“It doesn’t usually end at speech,” she said.

In contrast, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association said the current legal approach goes far enough.

READ MORE: Twitter bans ‘alt-right’ user accounts in apparent hate speech crackdown

The law is only engaged once speech crosses the line from hatred to inciting violence.

“We have often stood up for the right of people to say horrible, odious things that we disagree with because we think that a free democracy requires freedom of expression because the opposite is censorship,” said Sukanya Pillay, Executive Director and General Counsel for the CCLA.

Meanwhile, Schaefer shows no sign of backing down. His most recent video accused Jewish people of starting both World Wars.

Schaefer has not responded to a request for interview.

© 2016 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error

Comments

Comments closed.

Due to the sensitive and/or legal subject matter of some of the content on globalnews.ca, we reserve the ability to disable comments from time to time.

Please see our Commenting Policy for more.

Global News