Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is defending a suite of fall referendum questions aimed at immigration reform, saying “not every newcomer is a net contributor” to provincial coffers.
Smith announced in a TV address on Thursday evening that her United Conservative Party government is putting nine questions to a provincewide referendum on Oct. 19.
They include proposals to restrict health care, education and other social services from some immigrants and to open up constitutional negotiations on abolishing the Senate and giving provinces the power to appoint Superior Court judges.
However, the most controversial questions focus on immigration and they were also the topic of many of the questions at a Friday morning news conference hosted by Smith.
While immigration policy in Canada is primarily the responsibility of Ottawa, not the provinces, one of Smith’s referendum questions makes reference to “an Alberta-approved immigration status.”
Asked what that means, Smith took aim at a familiar foe, former prime minister Justin Trudeau, criticizing his government for accepting too many immigrants without “in-demand skills” calling his government’s immigration policies “absolutely unsustainable.”
Alberta’s population, which topped five million last year, according to Statistics Canada, added more than 600,000 people in the past five years — something Smith said has been putting a strain on provincial resources.
- Read the transcript of Trump’s response to U.S. Supreme Court tariff ruling
- Danielle Smith promises Alberta referendum over immigration, Constitution changes
- ‘No reason to continue discussing’: Ontario mayor wants Andrew’s name dropped
- Trump’s global tariffs were struck down. Don’t expect price drops: experts
“Throwing the doors wide open to anyone and everyone across the globe has flooded our classrooms, emergency rooms and social support systems with far too many people, far too quickly,” claimed Smith.
Smith announced the referendum questions at a time her government is facing a deficit of at least $6.4 billion, partly because of falling world oil prices but also a funding shortfall she blames on Alberta’s rapid population growth.
Get breaking National news
When pressed, Smith couldn’t provide a dollar amount on how much those who aren’t Canadian citizens or permanent residents are costing the public purse, but claimed other provinces already require employers and not the provincial government to cover health care costs.
The opposition NDP responded to Smith’s referendum questions, calling them a deceptive distraction from “a UCP budget that will contain billions of dollars in deficits along with the campaign for Alberta’s separation from Canada “which she put on the agenda.”
The premier is blaming oil prices and immigration “for her own poor planning and financial mismanagement,” said Deputy NDP Leader Raki Pancholi at a news conference in Edmonton on Friday, who added that Albertans will “see right through this.”
Referencing previous calls from the premier for more immigration, Pancholi said, “Less than two years ago, Danielle Smith herself asked Justin Trudeau to increase immigration levels because Alberta wanted more than what Ottawa was already allocating. In 2024, she stated publicly that she wanted to double Alberta’s population to 10 million people.”
“She did all this without a single thought or plan for how to create the jobs, build the houses, the schools, and hospitals that we already needed in this province,” added Pancholi, who also challenged Smith to call a provincial election.
“Let Albertans judge her performance in the last six years under the UCP. It’s all a massive distraction from the real things Albertans expect their government to deliver: health care, education, cost of living and good quality jobs,” Pancholi added.
Asked about Smith blaming immigrants, in part, for the province’s financial woes, Pancholi said, “I’m a public figure who has been in this role for about seven years now, and I can tell you that the level of racism and hate that has been expressed has risen undoubtedly in this province.”
Her concerns about the possible backlash against immigrants are shared by Sally Zhao, CEO of The Immigrant Education Society in Calgary.
“We’re worried about the already existing anti-immigration sentiment. So with this, will that become worse? We hope not,” said Zhao.
“And the long-term impact, well, I think immigrants are filling up a lot of employment labor market gaps. For example, hospitality and other service industries. We’re wondering, in the future, these industries rely on immigrants very heavily, ‘Where are they going to find workers? And in the long term, are we making Alberta a more desirable place for people to come, or we are making Alberta a less desirable place to come?'” added Zhao.
Gabriel Brunet, spokesman for Dominic LeBlanc, Canada’s minister for intergovernmental affairs, responded to Smith’s comments, saying the federal government had taken note of Smith’s address and had also taken measures to bring “control” back to the immigration system.
“Albertans will express their views on these issues and others raised by Premier Smith, as they have on several constitutional questions in the past,” Brunet said.
–with files from The Canadian Press.
For the car?
She’s an idiot, but hey keep voting her in and its the same in ontario we have a idiot as well. they need to put Canadian men and women first hospitals and medical and housing and poverty levels never been so high and the unemployment rates never been higher taking care of the people has never really been any politicians number 1 thing
Not Controversial but Democratic
I’m like Arthur. Another brain dead mo ron that can come up with a single argument against Smith. All I can say is “MAGA.” I dream about Trump as he occupies the two brain cells I have left.
Who let MAGA into Canada?
She ain’t wrong.
Then again I have virtually no brain cells left and have no other arguments other than things TDS related.
I have very few brain cells so the only arguments I can think of are MAGA this or MAGA that. Sorry folks.
I used to criticize her but now I realize how much effort she puts into safeguarding the welfare of her electorate. Alberta is lucky to have someone who defends them against the permanent blood sucking that is the federal government.
Racist, cheap political strategy right out of the MAGA play book. A total embarassment!