B.C.’s final legislative session before election ends with acrimony, tears, fantasies

Click to play video: 'Focus BC: BC United ruling out merger, unofficial start to election campaign'
Focus BC: BC United ruling out merger, unofficial start to election campaign
WATCH: To merge or not to merge. That is the question posed this week to both the BC Conservative and BC United parties. In the Friday, May 17, 2024, edition of Focus BC, host Richard Zussman speaks with BC United leader Kevin Falcon about the possibility of a merger and how the party is exploring options for cooperation. Also, David Coletto from Abacus Data has more on polling results on where the parties stand ahead of the October election. – May 17, 2024

The final legislative session before the coming B.C. provincial election ended last week in acrimony, tears and some wild political fantasies being circulated.

The acrimony resulted from the increased tension in the House that occurs anytime an election is approaching, as tempers get shorter and nerves become frayed.

The tears came with the departure of almost 20 MLAs, some of them long-serving veterans, as they made their farewell speeches in the House.

And the political fantasies revolved around talk of some kind of “merger” between the BC United party and the BC Conservative Party. Both United Leader Kevin Falcon and Conservative Leader John Rustad publicly mused about such a possibility and then just as quickly seemed to kibosh the idea.

Nevertheless, political tongues were wagging for about 48 hours last week as folks pondered how such an arrangement could be arrived at.

Story continues below advertisement

The idea of a merger or some kind of co-managed election campaign assumes that the centre-right vote is “split” between the two parties and if they could just get together it would create a common front that would deny the re-election of the NDP government.

Click to play video: 'Port Coquitlam Mayor Brad West sets record straight about his political future'
Port Coquitlam Mayor Brad West sets record straight about his political future

But this is where the word “fantasy” enters the picture.

First, political parties cannot merge their assets (i.e. money raised through fundraising and things like office equipment and hardware) so it is unclear what any kind of “merger” would actually look like.

Second, you can’t add the two parties’ polling numbers together and automatically assume that would be the level of support for a combined alternative. Some BC United voters would never vote for the BC Conservatives and vice-versa.

While the two parties share some policies there are critical differences between them that no amount of backroom work by political fixers will eliminate. The BC Conservatives are far more socially conservative than BC United.

Story continues below advertisement

Falcon seized on this point in talking to the media last week. Shortly after admitting his party executive had made “exploratory” overtures to the BC Conservative executive, he told the media about the main stumbling block to any kind of agreement between the two parties.

“I can’t merge with a party that has candidates that equate vaccines to Nazism and apartheid,” he told reporters. He was presumably referring to candidates like Damon Scrase, the BC Conservative Party candidate in the Courtenay-Comox riding, who has posted dozens of social media comments that equate vaccines to Nazism and apartheid (as well as a host of other far-right comments).

There is also the matter of electoral math. The NDP won 49 ridings in the 2020 election with at least 45 per cent of the vote in each of them and it won 36 ridings by at least the same margin in the 2017 election.

Of the six new seats appearing in the next election, at least three of them are in NDP strongholds, putting the party in a very strong position with more than 50 seats, barring a hemorrhage in voter support (47 seats are required for a majority government).

Click to play video: 'Political Panel: Merger talks with BC United and BC Conservatives'
Political Panel: Merger talks with BC United and BC Conservatives

Then there is the Green Party (remember it?).

Story continues below advertisement

It receives about 10 to 20 per cent of the vote in many Metro and Island ridings (it finished second to the NDP in a dozen ridings in 2020). That could mean that the combined BC United/BC Conservative support might not even exceed 40 per cent in many ridings, thus rendering a proposed merger somewhat pointless.

A wiser and potentially more effective move by Falcon and BC United is to aim their sights on the BC Conservatives with an eye to driving down that party’s support rather than cozying up to the much more right-wing entity.

Fighting a two-front war has its risks but given BC United’s beleaguered situation, it may be the only choice for the party.

Keith Baldrey is the chief political reporter for Global BC.

Sponsored content