Alberta UCP faces more opposition to municipalities bill: ‘I’m really concerned’

Click to play video: 'Alberta Municipalities ‘caught off guard’ by details of Bill 20'
Alberta Municipalities ‘caught off guard’ by details of Bill 20
WATCH ABOVE (April 30): Reaction continues to the UCP’s Bill 20. The legislation aims to give the province broad authority to dismiss local elected officials and overturn municipal bylaws. The organization that represents Alberta cities, towns, and villages suggests the proposed changes would create an “atmosphere of fear.” Tyler Gandam, president of Alberta Municipalities, joined Global News at Noon to express his views. – Apr 30, 2024

It was a long time ago, but Jan Novotny still remembers the tanks rumbling through his hometown of Prague in 1968 when the Soviet Union enforced its will on the people of what was then Czechoslovakia.

On Monday, he stood outside the Alberta legislature in a gentle rain, holding a sign aimed at the province’s United Conservative Party government saying, “Stalin Would Be Proud.”

“I’m really concerned,” Novotny said on the first day of his protest.

“Democracy is a slippery slope. It can slip into autocracy quite easily. I just find the current government very autocratic in nature.”

Novotny is specifically concerned about a proposed law that would grant Premier Danielle Smith’s cabinet sweeping power to fire local councillors, toss out bylaws, and allow political parties to run in Edmonton and Calgary.

Story continues below advertisement

The office of Municipal Affairs Minister Ric McIver did not respond to a question about how much feedback it has received on its proposed legislation, which was introduced April 25.

McIver has promised to amend the bill and discuss the proposed changes with municipal leaders, who say they should have been consulted before the bill was even introduced.

But on Monday, when asked by reporters on the state of consultations, McIver pointed to the fact he already spoke with multiple leaders “over the last few days” about the impending changes.

When asked if he considered those discussions to be the promised consultation, McIver declined to clarify.

“It’s one form of consultation, it’s certainly not the only form,” he replied.

Click to play video: 'Calgary Mayor on marathon rezoning session at City Hall and her thoughts on the UCP’s Bill 20'
Calgary Mayor on marathon rezoning session at City Hall and her thoughts on the UCP’s Bill 20

Like other bills and policy balloons Albertans have seen since the 2023 provincial election, it wasn’t part of the UCP’s campaign platform and hasn’t gone before a public comment process.

Story continues below advertisement

Novotny is one of an undetermined but increasingly vocal number of Albertans who are concerned about what they call the government’s bossiness.

“I just woke up and said enough is enough,” said Glenda Tailfeathers of Lethbridge, who’s helping organize “Enough Is Enough” protests in several Alberta communities for May 25.

“There’s a lot of interest in people taking a stand,” said Peter Oliver of Project Alberta, an offshoot of a group called Project Calgary.

In one day, the group collected 800 signatures against the proposed legislation.

“The more power they take away from our councils, the more power they put in the hands of corporations and unions,” Oliver said. “It could reach a point where it’s hard to get control back.”

Last week, University of Alberta political science professor Jared Wesley posted an essay warning of a growing authoritarian streak in the UCP government.

“In my two decades of research, I haven’t seen this sort of reaction to anything I’ve written,” Wesley said in an email.

“It’s not just the volume, but the variety of people reaching out. From the left and the right. CEOs to retirees, rural folks and city folks. All of them upset at what a growing number of Albertans are seeing: a government bent on consolidating power.

Story continues below advertisement

“You can feel the groundswell, and MLAs are hearing it, too.”

This weekend, Craig Snodgrass, the mayor of High River – Premier Danielle Smith’s hometown — said the only reason the bill is on the table is because the UCP has failed to get “their people” into the mayor’s seat in Edmonton and Calgary.

“This is about control. It won’t end with the big cities. Scrap it,” Snodgrass wrote on social media.

McIver said last week the amendments will address those concerns but has not provided specifics.

Alberta Municipalities — the organization that speaks for towns, cities, and villages — has also objected.

“Albertans have been clear: they do not want political parties in their local elections,” the organization said in a statement last week. “The provincial government has ignored them, too, deaf to the voices of Albertans.”

Click to play video: 'Alberta Municipalities speaks out over province’s Bill 20 to have more control over local politics'
Alberta Municipalities speaks out over province’s Bill 20 to have more control over local politics

Tyler Gandam, president of Alberta Municipalities confirmed that McIver called him last week to say changes were coming, but said that has been it.

Story continues below advertisement

“Minister McIver committed to consulting with Alberta Municipalities in advance of the announcement of the forthcoming amendments, but nothing has been arranged yet,” Gandam said in a statement.

“I trust we will have the opportunity to address our concerns on all parts of the bill,” he said.

Paul McLauchlin, head of Rural Municipalities of Alberta, told CHED radio Monday he has had “discussions” with McIver.

While McLauchlin said he’s hopeful McIver has heard the organization’s concerns and will make necessary changes, he said nobody was asking for a bill making it easier for cabinet to remove local councillors or mayors.

It’s not clear when the amendments will be brought to the floor of the legislature.

Asked Monday about the timeline, McIver said, “When amendments are ready, we will introduce them in the house.”

McIver said time is a factor. He said the government aims to ensure the bill passes debate in the legislature in the current sitting, which is scheduled to rise at the end of the month.

Critics say the Smith government has a way of springing controversial legislation on Albertans.

In the last year, the government has: re-introduced the idea of a provincial pension; imposed a moratorium on approvals for renewable power; promised to restrict gender-affirming care for young people; and introduced legislation that would require provincially regulated organizations, including universities, to obtain provincial approvals on federal funding.

Story continues below advertisement

Smith has pushed back on criticisms, saying her government is simply responding to concerns from stakeholders and is committed to ensuring other levels of government don’t overstep their authority.

— with files from Lisa Johnson, The Canadian Press

Sponsored content