COVID-19: Quebec drops vaccination mandate for health-care workers

Click to play video: 'Do COVID-19 vaccine mandates really put health care systems at risk?'
Do COVID-19 vaccine mandates really put health care systems at risk?
Do COVID-19 vaccine mandates really put health care systems at risk? – Nov 4, 2021

Quebec is backtracking on its enforced COVID-19 vaccination mandate for health-care workers, government officials announced Wednesday.

After pushing back its deadline multiple times, Health Minister Christian Dubé said the province will abandon the measure altogether, as the health-care network can’t afford to lose the thousands of non-vaccinated employees.

The loss of unvaccinated staff would have had a “devastating effect on the system,” according to the health ministry.

READ MORE: Polling the unvaccinated: Why Canadians say they won’t get a COVID vaccine

The province’s plan to suspend unvaccinated workers as of Nov. 15 would have forced the health sector to cut services and would have compromised efforts to improve working conditions for all employees.

While 97 per cent of those who work in Quebec’s heath-care system are vaccinated, 14,000 haven’t received a first dose, and of those, 5,000 are in direct contact with patients.

Story continues below advertisement

While vaccination will no longer be mandatory for current employees, Dubé added that all new health-care hires will have to be vaccinated.

Unvaccinated staff will be obliged to get tested for COVID three times a week, and those who don’t comply will be suspended without pay.

READ MORE: Doctors outraged as Ontario, Quebec deny COVID-19 vaccine mandates for health workers

The government had originally set an Oct. 15 deadline for all workers to be vaccinated but extended it in the hopes of convincing the remaining staff to get their shots.

The vaccination rate among health-care workers has gone up from about 90 per cent to 97 since the government first announced its intention in August to impose a mandate.

Dr. Donald Vinh, an infectious disease specialist at the McGill University Health Centre (MUHC), said the Quebec government has dug itself into a hole by making such a move, which could backfire.

“I worry that it’s not the science that is guiding the policy decision-making,” Vinh said.

“Health-care workers who are inadequately vaccinated will find themselves at higher risk of needing to be hospitalized,” he added.

READ MORE: Ontario will not mandate COVID-19 vaccines for hospital workers

Michel Lachance, an unvaccinated paramedic who is part of an ongoing lawsuit against the province’s vaccine mandate, told Global News he is relieved. “I am really happy, it relieves a weight that I [have had] for a couple of months now,” said Lachance.
Story continues below advertisement

“It was the legal and correct decision,” said Natalia Manole, a lawyer representing unvaccinated employees in the lawsuit.

Daniel Desharnais, an assistant deputy minister in charge of liaising with the local health networks, said the province’s health system is so short-staffed that a labour reduction of even one per cent would have “very damaging effects.” Applying the decree would have resulted in a reduction in labour hours of about four per cent overall and up to nine per cent in some services, he said.

Desharnais said a reduction in services in areas such as home care or long-term care could have a domino effect on other services by forcing patients to stay in crowded hospitals longer.

The health minister however warned the unvaccinated workers that the province would likely replace unvaccinated staff as soon as they have enough vaccinated employees from which to choose.

Health officials have repeatedly stressed that vaccination against COVID-19 is necessary to protect vulnerable patients.

–with files from The Canadian Press and Saba Aziz, Global News


Sponsored content