B.C. school killer’s mental illness defence relies on his own word he saw monsters: Crown

Click to play video: 'Criminal responsibility hearing for Gabriel Klein' Criminal responsibility hearing for Gabriel Klein
Criminal responsibility hearing for Gabriel Klein – Jan 14, 2021

A Crown prosecutor says there’s no reliable evidence to support an argument that a man who stabbed two high school girls in Abbotsford, B.C., was having a psychotic break and didn’t realize they were human.

Gabriel Klein was convicted of second-degree murder and aggravated assault in March for the 2016 attack that killed 13-year-old Letisha Reimer and injured her friend.

Click to play video: 'Final arguments in hearing for Gabriel Klein' Final arguments in hearing for Gabriel Klein
Final arguments in hearing for Gabriel Klein – Jan 13, 2021

Read more: Court hears final arguments over criminal responsibility of Abbotsford school killer

Story continues below advertisement

Closing arguments are underway in a hearing in which Klein’s lawyer has argued his client should not be held criminally responsible because he suffered a mental disorder that led him to believe he was stabbing monsters.

However, Crown prosecutor Rob Macgowan said the judge hearing the case would have to accept Klein’s version of events in order to rule in his favour.

Click to play video: 'Gabriel Klein convicted of second degree murder in Abbotsford school killing' Gabriel Klein convicted of second degree murder in Abbotsford school killing
Gabriel Klein convicted of second degree murder in Abbotsford school killing – Mar 6, 2020

“If you don’t accept Klein’s word for it, we submit that all you would be left with is the same body of evidence upon which he was found guilty of murder and aggravated assault,” Macgowan told the judge Thursday.

The B.C. Supreme Court has heard that Klein was waiting in a rotunda that connects Abbotsford Senior Secondary with a public library when he encountered the girls.

READ MORE: Gabriel Klein found guilty of 2nd-degree murder in Abbotsford high school stabbing

He testified in court that he was feeling suicidal and was waiting to use a library computer to email his mother. As he waited, he said he saw a witch and zombie with maggots coming out of its back and heard a voice telling him to “kill” before he stabbed them.

Story continues below advertisement

He did not realize what he had done until after the fact, he told the court. He was later diagnosed with several mental disorders, including schizophrenia, while in custody awaiting trial.

In order to be found not criminally responsible by reason of a mental disorder under the Criminal Code, the judge must conclude that Klein was suffering a mental disorder that made him incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of his crime, or of understanding that it was wrong.

Click to play video: 'New video from murder trial shows theft of weapon' New video from murder trial shows theft of weapon
New video from murder trial shows theft of weapon – Jan 13, 2020

Macgowan said Klein has not suggested he couldn’t understand that stabbing people could result in their death, nor that stabbing people is wrong.

Instead, Macgowan said Klein’s case rests on the judge finding he did not appreciate the fact that he was stabbing people.

“That is the nature of Mr. Klein’s defence,” Macgowan said.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: Newly released video shows Gabriel Klein in run-up to fatal stabbing of Abbotsford teen

The problem is that any evidence confirming Klein’s perceptions at the time leads back to his own words, including reports or testimony from expert witnesses who say they believe Klein’s claims, Macgowan argued. Case law indicates it’s the court’s jurisdiction to make a finding of fact, not the expert witnesses.

Klein has offered varying accounts of what he saw, what the voices in his head told him, and the events leading up to the attack, Macgowan said.

Martin Peters, Klein’s lawyer, said Wednesday that there is general consensus among experts that schizophrenia and memories arising from psychotic events cause deficits in working memory. Inconsistencies, contradictions and imprecisions in memories of psychotic episodes are not unusual and are to be expected, Klein said.

READ MORE: Manslaughter or murder? Man accused of killing Abbotsford student to learn fate in February

But Macgowan argued that doesn’t make Klein a reliable witness.

“The presence of internal inconsistencies are not rendered irrelevant the moment someone claims to be in a psychotic state,” Macgowan said.

Story continues below advertisement

Beyond the incident, he has admitted in court to lying on several occasions, including regarding an account of being robbed by someone dressed as a clown, and during a conversation with one of the doctors examining him, Macgowan said.

Sponsored content