David Ayer accused of ‘brownfacing’ after casting Shia LaBeouf in upcoming crime film

Shia LaBeouf attends the 23rd annual Hollywood Film Awards at the Beverly Hilton Hotel on Nov. 3, 2019 in Beverly Hills, Calif. Lionel Hahn/ABACAPRESS.COM

Following the release of the debut trailer for his upcoming crime-thriller film The Tax Collector, director David Ayer has been accused of “brownfacing” after casting actor Shia LaBeouf as one of the film’s characters.

After the trailer’s release, multiple Twitter users questioned Ayer’s decision to cast LaBeouf in the role.

Tell all the kids how you’re Hollywood’s top cholo auteur, and your pretzel reasons Shia Lebeouf (sic) is sort of kind of playing a weird movie cholo in a cop movie and how all of this isn’t really #brownfacing,” one user wrote on the social media platform hours after the trailer’s worldwide premiere.

“You just told them,” Ayers, 52, tweeted in response. “It ain’t a cop movie. And Shia is playing something very specific. Not brownface.”

Story continues below advertisement

The backlash was seemingly prompted after viewers noticed that The Tax Collector’s trailer highlights LaBeouf’s appearance in the film specifically, as opposed to any of the other actors — who, for the most part, are Latin American.

Though LaBeouf, 34, was given the spotlight in the two-minute, 20-second teaser, actor Bobby Soto actually holds the leading role, according to Ayer.

Read more: Ryan Adams apologizes after sexual misconduct allegations — ‘I will never be off the hook’

When asked why he “(centred) a white person in a story that capitalizes on Latino culture,” Ayer tweeted: “Respectfully, I didn’t.”

Story continues below advertisement

“Bobby Soto is the lead,” he said. “Shia has a supporting role. He’s the only non-POC cast member.”

“Hey, really important question that I think you should answer publicly in 2020,” another user wrote in response to the trailer.

“Is Shia Lebouf (sic) playing a Latino character in Tax Collector? If so, why didn’t you cast a Latin actor?” the Twitter user asked the Suicide Squad director.

“Really important answer,” Ayers, 52, tweeted in response. “Shia is playing a white boy who grew up in the hood. This is a Jewish dude playing a white character. Also the only white dude in the movie.”

Story continues below advertisement

Read more: J.K. Rowling under fire for describing hormone therapy as ‘conversion therapy for young gay people’


Ayer faced similar criticism about casting for his 2012 thriller End of Watch. The movie, which starred Jake Gyllenhaal and Michael Peña, was criticized for almost exclusively depicting Black and Latinx criminals, according to NME.

LaBeouf has not publicly addressed the backlash as of this writing.

As described in the trailer’s description on YouTube, The Tax Collector follows two tax collectors — Soto (who plays David) and LaBeouf (Creeper) — who work under the wing of a crime boss by the name of Wizard.

Upon the unexpected return of Wizard’s rival from Mexico, their business is upended. As a result, David’s new priority becomes protecting his family.

The upcoming action film also features actors George Lopez and Cinthya Carmona, among many others.


Story continues below advertisement

The Tax Collector is currently scheduled for a North America-wide release on Aug. 7.

The debut trailer can be seen in the video above.

Sponsored content