Advertisement

Pro-life group wins appeal against $17,500 protest security fee at U of A

An image of an informational booth run by the UAlberta Pro-Life group. The group has won a challenge against a security fee implemented against it by the University of Alberta. .
An image of an informational booth run by the UAlberta Pro-Life group. The group has won a challenge against a security fee implemented against it by the University of Alberta. . Facebook / UAlberta Pro-Life

A pro-life group has won an appeal in Alberta’s highest court, against a University of Alberta security fee that the school had implemented following a controversial protest in 2015.

The decision comes after more than four years of back and forth court issues between the university and the UAlberta Pro-Life group.

The initial 2015 protest from Pro-Life saw a large display that featured images of fetuses put up in the university’s main quad, leading to a large counter-demonstration from other students and faculty.

Then in 2016, when UAlberta Pro-Life applied to hold another anti-abortion protest, the university said that the group would have to pay $17,500 for security fees.

Unable to pay this fee, the group was forced to cancel its planned protest.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: ‘We feel as if we’re being made to pay for our free speech:’ anti-abortion group on U of A security cost estimate for event

Pro-Life then sought a judicial review of that fee, as well what it said was a lack of discipline from the university towards the counter protests, which Pro-Life said went against the University Code of Student Behavior.

“In issuing this demand [of the fee], the University of Alberta ignored the fact that any threat to safety and security that may have existed on campus came uniquely from those who physically obstructed and loudly interrupted a university-approved event,” said lawyer John Carpay, who is president of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, which represents the students in their court action.

LISTEN BELOW: Danielle Smith speaks with Jay Cameron with the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedom

Both the initial court challenges were dismissed in 2017 when Justice Bonnie Bokenfohr ruled that UAlberta Pro-Life was treated fairly and the university was within its right to require the club to pay for security if it wanted to hold another protest.

READ MORE: No review of how University of Alberta handled anti abortion group’s demonstration

On Monday Jan. 6, the Alberta Court of Appeal ruled in favour of UAlberta Pro-Life in regards to the security costs issues.

Story continues below advertisement

In the decision, the court also ruled in favour of the university regarding the complaint around discipline.

A university spokesperson said in a statement Monday that “the University of Alberta will be reviewing the decision in detail and therefore reserves further comment at this time.”

Alberta’s conscience rights bill for doctors causes controversy
Alberta’s conscience rights bill for doctors causes controversy