‘Worst’ anti-Semitic hate crime at Winnipeg cafe allegedly faked by owners, say police

‘Worst’ anti-Semitic hate crime at Winnipeg cafe was allegedly faked by owners, say police
WATCH: Police said charges have been laid against the owners of a Corydon Avenue cafe that was allegedly robbed and vandalized with anti-Semitic graffiti April 18.

An incident at a Corydon Avenue cafe that was originally reported as one of Winnipeg’s worst-ever hate crimes was apparently staged, said police.

Three owners of the BerMax Caffé were arrested Wednesday and charged with public mischief, which involves intent to mislead and causing an officer to investigate an incident based on false information.

The cafe was allegedly robbed, the interior trashed and the walls spray-painted with anti-Semitic graffiti on April 18, although investigators now say that was all staged by the owners.

READ MORE: Winnipeg cafe targeted with anti-Semitic graffiti

At the time, Winnipeg police Const. Rob Carver told media the attack was one of the “worst” hate crimes he had seen as a police officer.

Story continues below advertisement

Police Chief Danny Smyth said Wednesday the investigation has been a significant waste of police resources.

“Over 25 officers have invested nearly 1,000 hours through a busy holiday weekend trying to bring this investigation to a close,” he said.

“In the end, we found evidence of a crime. It just wasn’t a hate crime.”

The incident sparked a large outpouring of support from people in Winnipeg’s Jewish community and the city at large, including an interfaith prayer vigil planned by a local church for Thursday night.

READ MORE: Church plans vigil for Winnipeg Jewish community following cafe hate crime

“There have been some new developments in the BerMax Caffé situation,” said a spokesperson for Westworth United Church. “These are being reviewed, and an announcement on the status of the interfaith prayer vigil will follow.”

Alexander, Oxana and Maxim Berent are all facing charges and have reportedly been released on a promise to appear.

Winnipeg mayor Brian Bowman spoke out against the alleged hate crime when it was first reported. He said if the charges against the owners are proven, it will represent a major breach of trust within the community, as well as a “complete waste of police resources”.

Story continues below advertisement
‘Disgusting’: Winnipeg mayor reacts to charges against cafe owners for faking anti-Semitic attack
‘Disgusting’: Winnipeg mayor reacts to charges against cafe owners for faking anti-Semitic attack

“If the charges are upheld by a court, it’s disgusting,” Bowman said.

READ MORE: False reports of hate crimes few and far between, says expert

“We are shocked and deeply disturbed by today’s news,” said the Winnipeg Jewish Federation in a statement Wednesday afternoon.

“It is deplorable that anyone would make false allegations of anti-Semitism, especially claims of such a serious nature, for any kind of gain,” the organization said.

“Filing false complaints of criminal acts of anti-Semitism (is) not only illegal, they undermine the important work necessary to counter anti-Semitism and hate in all forms.”

A GoFundMe page had been set up to support the café after a previous incident last month.

Story continues below advertisement

Robbie Kfir Mulder-Kiesman, who set up the fundraiser, said in a statement that fundraising efforts have been suspended until more information is available.

“We are aware of the announcements made and have been taken completely off guard by the information,” said Mulder-Kiesman.

“We took on this effort with the best intentions and hope that further information comes to light that provides the much needed answers we need in this situation.”

WATCH: Actor Jussie Smollett billed $130,106 USD by city of Chicago, the cost of investigating his fake hate crime claim

Jussie Smollett faces deadline to pay back city of Chicago
Jussie Smollett faces deadline to pay back city of Chicago

—With files from Hannah Owczar