December 10, 2018 5:27 pm
Updated: December 11, 2018 10:43 am

Controversial nativity scene shocks at St. Joseph’s Oratory

"Say cheese," Joseph and Mary take a photo with their new baby Jesus in this nativity scene at Montreal's St. Joseph's Oratory.

Modern Nativity/Facebook

With Christmas around the corner, Montreal’s St. Joseph’s Oratory’s nativity scene, complete with baby Jesus, Mary and Joseph, is taking centre stage.

But there’s something a little off about the scene meant to depict the birth of Christ — Joseph is taking a selfie and Mary is holding a Starbucks coffee cup and throwing up a peace sign.

Story continues below

READ MORE: Major facelift for St-Joseph’s Oratory will allow public access to previously forbidden areas

It’s part of the oratory’s display of nativity scenes from around the world in its museum.

It also features the Three Wise Men arriving at the birth, complete with black sunglasses and Segways, their parcels at hand with their gifts for baby Jesus.

The oratory insists the scene isn’t making fun of the holy holiday, saying it was meant to make people smile.

READ MORE: New archbishop, new attitude atop Montreal Catholic diocese

“I’m not surprised in a certain way. We knew that this was something so contemporary that people could be offended,” said Chantal Turbide, the museum’s curator.

“Either they like it a lot and they laugh or it could be shocking for some people.”

She points out the goal is to show that religion can be fun — while also pointing out our modern flaws.

“It’s kind of a mirror; people see themselves. That’s what is maybe surprising or shocking,” Turbide mused.

“They have to see themselves and think about their habits or their society. It’s a universal subject — it’s the birth of a child represented in different ways.”

WATCH BELOW: Iconic St-Joseph’s Oratory to get dazzling facelift

The figurines are part of a permanent exhibition and have actually been at the oratory for the last two years.

“Some people are OK with, some maybe like a more traditional way to see the scene,” explained Danielle Decelles, spokesperson for the oratory.

More than 100 countries are represented in the exhibition.

READ MORE: St. Joseph’s Oratory appeals to be excluded from sexual assault class action

“It’s a paradox because the tradition says that since the Middle Ages, since the start of the representation of the nativity, every region can represent Christ in their way,” Turbide told Global News.

“It’s not traditional, but it’s in the traditional way of representing it.”

© 2018 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error


Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.