‘Concerning’ information related to alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur triggers internal police probe

Lead detective in Bruce McArthur investigation files complaint against fellow officer
WATCH ABOVE: A complaint has been filed by the lead detective in the Bruce McArthur investigation against a fellow officer. As Catherine McDonald reports, it relates to a detective who interviewed Bruce McArthur in 2016 after a complaint was made.

TORONTO – A veteran detective leading the investigation into alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur said Wednesday that in the course of his work on the case he came across “concerning” information that has now triggered an internal police probe.

Det. Sgt. Hank Idsinga wouldn’t provide further details, but said he became aware of the information after reviewing two previous police investigations into five missing men from Toronto’s Church-Wellesley Village.

“I saw something I felt needed to be investigated further,” he said in an interview.

READ MORE: Bruce McArthur had me in a ‘kill position,’ says Toronto man haunted by date with alleged serial killer

Last week, Idsinga prepared a report with his findings and sent it to the force’s professional standards unit.

“I think you should take a look at this because we’re accountable for what we do,” he said he told the internal investigators.

Story continues below advertisement

“I’m not the one to decide whether mistakes are made or not, but I think it’s something that certainly needs to be investigated. It was concerning.”

EXTENDED: Catherine McDonald speaks one-on-one with Det. Sgt. Hank Idsinga

Extended: Lead detective in Bruce McArthur investigation goes one-on-one with Global News
Extended: Lead detective in Bruce McArthur investigation goes one-on-one with Global News

Police spokeswoman Meaghan Gray said the force’s professional standards unit launched the internal investigation on Monday, but she also declined to discuss the nature of the information that prompted the probe.

A police source told Global News that McArthur was spoken to in 2016 regarding a complaint. The complaint was unrelated to the missing men investigation.

Idsinga said he was made aware of a complaint when he was overseeing Project Prism, a task force looking into missing men Selim Esen and Andrew Kinsman, in the fall of 2017.

Story continues below advertisement

LISTEN: Toronto Mayor John Tory calls for independent review of missing persons cases

At the time Idsinga had some concern about how that complaint was handled, but said he waited to go to professional standards “because (of) the investigation that we’re undertaking, we can’t expose that investigation, the murder investigation.”

Idsinga wouldn’t provide further details on the reason he went to professional standards.

McArthur, a 66-year-old self-employed landscaper, has since been charged with four more counts of first-degree murder. All six alleged victims had ties to the city’s gay village.

READ MORE: Police release photo of body of man linked to alleged Toronto serial killer Bruce McArthur

Members of the city’s LGBTQ community have complained for years that police were ignoring their concerns about a possible serial killer on the loose. Late last year, Toronto police assured the community that there was no known link between the different missing person cases.

Story continues below advertisement

Gray said police were aware of the concerns and willing to work with the community to find solutions.

“We know this information will be disappointing to some members of the community,” she said in a statement. “In addition to listening to their concerns, we have always said we are open to a public inquiry into these investigations and Chief (Mark) Saunders has already taken steps to consider what areas can be reviewed right now, during the ongoing investigation.”

Mayor John Tory issued a statement saying he’s “deeply disturbed” by the revelations.

“I support open and transparent reviews of how our police service handles missing person cases generally and how these specific investigations were conducted,” Tory said, noting he and the public have many questions related to the case.

Police have recovered the remains of seven people from planter pots found at a home in midtown Toronto where the 66-year-old self-employed landscaper stored equipment.

Over the years police have launched two projects into the disappearance of men from the gay village.

LISTEN: 640 Toronto law enforcement analyst and former Toronto police chief Julian Fantino

Story continues below advertisement

The first police probe – named Project Houston – was launched in 2012 to investigate the disappearance of three men: Skandaraj Navaratnam, 40, Majeed Kayhan, 58, and Abdulbasir Faizi, 42.

Idsinga said he became involved with that project when police found some evidence suggesting that Navaratnam “had met with foul play.” The investigation involved looking into “online cannibalism groups,” he said.

“We essentially investigated that to determine if it was reality or fantasy – we determined it was fantasy,” he said.

By 2014, police had closed Project Houston, saying none of their findings would classify anyone as a suspect of a criminal offence.

READ MORE: Homicide investigating tip from neighbour who used to live near alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur

“There was nothing pointing to McArthur at that time,” Idsinga said.

In August 2017, police launched Project Prism, which looked into the disappearances of two men from Toronto’s gay village – Andrew Kinsman, 48, and Selim Esen, 44.

VIDEO: Internal Toronto police probe related to Bruce McArthur investigation. Farah Nasser gets insight from retired police officer

Internal Toronto police probe related to Bruce McArthur investigation
Internal Toronto police probe related to Bruce McArthur investigation

At some point between those two projects, sources said, police interviewed McArthur for an unrelated incident, but homicide detectives involved in the latest investigation, which led to McArthur’s arrest, didn’t find out about that interview until recently.

Story continues below advertisement

McArthur popped up onto police radar in the fall of 2017 as part of Project Prism, which has now turned into a murder investigation, Idsinga said.

“It’s not until November that we find some evidence that leads us to believe Andrew Kinsman may have met with foul play and Bruce McArthur is a suspect in whatever offence has been committed against Andrew Kinsman,” Idsinga said.

READ MORE: B.C. man recalls the night he ‘escaped death’ at a suspected serial killer’s hands

“It’s Jan. 17 where we find some evidence that not only are Andrew Kinsman and Selim Esen dead and murdered, but that Bruce McArthur is a suspect in those murders.”

Police have since charged McArthur with murder in the deaths of Kinsman, Esen, Kayhan, Navaratnam, Dean Lisowick and Soroush Mahmudi.

— With files from Catherine McDonald