The CIA’s use of drones to hunt down and kill would-be terrorists has been widely denounced as the Obama administration is using more drones than ever.
In January alone, there were 15 covert operations that killed up to 120 people.
Then on Monday, a highly classified memo that was leaked to NBC News the legal justification the Obama administration was using to kill Americans abroad. The language was vague – drones were used when threats were “imminent” – which critics say is highly troubling. It even justified using drones to kill if there was no direct threat.
The Washington Post – and others – insist transparency is vital. “Does the secret war really have to be so secret?”
“Though it has ordered hundreds of drone strikes that have killed thousands, the Obama administration has never disclosed the methodology in the playbook. It has not provided public reports on the targets and results of drone strikes and, in the case of Pakistan, still officially refuses to acknowledge them. It has refused to disclose the Justice Department memos authorizing the operations, including attacks on U.S. citizens, even though one of the administration’s early acts in 2009 was to release war-on-terror Justice Department memos drawn up by the George W. Bush administration.”
The Post also argues that the attacks have been widely publicized – so why are officials being so secretive?
“…the attacks and their origin long ago ceased to be secret in any meaningful way. They are reported by the Pakistani press and hotly debated by the country’s politicians; what’s missing is official U.S. information. War should not be waged according to secret rules without legislative review or sufficient oversight.”
Get daily National news
The Guardian spoke with Aaron David Miller, a Middle East adviser to both Republican and Democrat administrations. And Miller had some harsh criticism for Obama, calling him “George W. Bush on steroids.”
“From the very first days of his presidency, Mr. Obama’s training as a lawyer was put to use not in abolishing the worst practices of the Bush era, but in giving himself the wriggle room to preserve and in some cases expand them. Thus the three major policies of the Bush war on terror – rendition, military commissions and indefinite detention – continue to this day. But Mr. Obama has also presided over a massive expansion of secret surveillance of American citizens by the National Security Agency. There is a ferocious crackdown on whistleblowers. He has made more government documents classified than any previous president. And he has become a true believer in drones.”
The Daily Times in Pakistan says it understands why the U.S. wants to ensure a tragedy like the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks never happens again – but at what cost?
“It has led to an entire gamut of actions taken in response, starting with the invasion of Afghanistan, which has proved to be a long drawn out battle that has too little to show for itself…and this war has also brought with it a complete disregard for human rights.”
“The U.S. has protected itself by involving countries where it could detain and torture suspects, with Pakistan being one of them. Pakistan, on the other hand, has drawn up its own parallels with such torture and detention centres in Balochistan, where missing persons cases are on the rise, and in FATA. We have inherited a dark legacy courtesy the US. The US must be asked: however just the cause, i.e. the struggle against terrorism, can it be successfully fought through unjust means?”
The Times goes on to say that drone strikes aren’t the answer to fighting the war on terror.
“The drone strikes are considered controversial and the information obtained by the CIA’s methods of interrogation has led to the outrage of many human rights groups. The U.S. must desist from such practices globally and so must its allies. It is imperative that the judicial, legal and prosecution systems be strengthened the world over instead of depending upon inhumane and illegal acts such as rendition and torture.”
The Washington Times suggests these drone attacks could trigger dangerous repercussions.
“It’s not hard to imagine a future when the nation’s commander in chief could extend the same reasoning to justify the targeting of dissident Americans on U.S. soil. All it would take is the labeling of groups as “domestic terrorists” who pose an imminent threat. That’s easy to do in a process that has no oversight.”
The use of drones could also backfire on the U.S. “Moreover, as advanced drone technologies become cheaper and proliferate, today’s operations could invite a future enemy to employ similar justification for sending its own drones into American skies to take out persons – Americans or otherwise – considered hostile combatants.”
And with civilians ending up as collateral damage in some of these attacks, the Sacramento Bee issues this warning: “If the people in Pakistan, Yemen and other countries hit by drone strikes turn against America, doesn’t that damage U.S. interests and national security in the long run?”
With other nations trying to get their hands on drones, they’ll be looking to the U.S. for guidance, says the New York Times. “More than 50 nations have or are trying to get the technology. The United States will set the standard for them all.”
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.