August 9, 2017 11:36 am
Updated: August 10, 2017 8:39 am

The new norm? Registries for children’s birthday parties

WATCH: Registries are a new birthday party trend that are creating controversy in the parenting world. Global's Felicia Parrillo explains.

A A

If you are invited to a wedding or baby shower, you can expect to be invited to choose a gift from a registry drawn up by the host — but have you heard of registries for children’s birthday parties?

The new trend is creating controversy among parents.

READ MORE: Police save 7-year-old’s birthday party after no friends show up

Story continues below

“Most kids have way too much stuff,” said mom Tanya Bagshaw.

“I would not want to encourage my kids to create a list of ‘I wants’ and expect to receive a lot of presents.”

Mother Guyane Hébert-Potter told Global News she has made registries with Toys “R” Us in the past.

The store refers to their registries as “wish lists.”

READ MORE: Parents explore low-cost, low-stress birthday parties

She explained she made the list to give friends and family ideas for her daughter’s baby shower, baptism and birthday.

She said she scoured the Toys “R” Us website for hours composing the wish list.

WATCH BELOW: Mother cuts birthday party costs with creativity

“There were so many options, I had to compare brands, look at reviews and choose a price point,” said Hébert-Potter.

To eliminate the possibility of ending up with duplicate items, the host and guests can see what has already been purchased.

READ MORE: Saskatoon girls donate birthday money to new children’s hospital

“I knew what I was getting, so I was unwrapping just to see those items,” said Hébert-Potter.

“It took away from the emotional aspect and the element of surprise.”

However, she says not many guests referred to the wish list when buying gifts.

WATCH BELOW: How to throw an activity-filled birthday party

Hébert-Potter mentioned that the list, “implements a budget, and limits guests.”

In the end, she said she only received about 10 to 20 per cent of what was on the list.

The debate caused controversy among parents, as some parents argued that creating a registry for a child’s birthday party is unsuitable.

READ MORE: ‘Best party ever’: Georgetown boy celebrates 7th birthday with help from community

“A registry for a child is really extra in my opinion. I find asking for specific things from peers kind of inappropriate,” said mom Rebecca Young Sargent.

“Family is one thing, but family asks the parent. I see no need for a registry.”

Hébert-Potter told Global News she won’t be making wish lists in the future.

“I’m sure it works for some people, but I didn’t get the results I wanted,” she said.

© 2017 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error

Comments

Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.

Global News