The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal has thrown out, for a second time, the first-degree murder conviction of an Ottawa man who claimed he had no idea his friend planned to shoot the victim in the head.
Steven Gareau has been ordered to face a new trial – it would be his third – although the court ruling pointedly noted a retrial is “at the Crown’s discretion.”
Get breaking National news
The dead man, Sean Simmons, had been targeted in October 2000 because he’d had an affair with a girlfriend of a member of the Hells Angels.
The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal ruled Wednesday that the trial judge mistakenly allowed the jury to hear about a second, earlier shooting, and mishandled wiretap evidence suggesting Gareau wasn’t aware of a murder plot.
- Toronto man arrested for homicide after appearing on Canada’s most wanted list
- 2 former Montreal police officers charged in misconduct investigation
- Calgary man pleads guilty to threatening to kill Prime Minister Mark Carney and family
- Tenants ordered to vacate ‘state-of-chaos’ apartment building in central Edmonton
Gareau’s first conviction for both murder and conspiracy to commit murder came in 2004, but it was overturned eight years later because of different legal mistakes by a different judge.
He was retried over seven months and convicted again in February 2014.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.