TORONTO – Fewer than five per cent of Canadians would support regulations that allow retailers to charge credit card holders extra for using their plastic for payments, a survey released Thursday by a consumer group suggests.
But the poll for the Consumers Association of Canada also indicated few Canadians are aware that the federal competition watchdog is pushing to amend rules that prevent retailers from passing on the cost of a surcharge levied on them by Visa and MasterCard.
The Competition Bureau is challenging rules made by credit card companies that charge retailers between 1.5 and three per cent per credit card transaction – but prevent them from jacking up prices to offset the extra amount.
Retailers have always paid fees to cover the cost of processing credit card transactions but merchants began to campaign against them a few years ago after card issuers started to charge more for certain premium cards.
Retailers have applauded the bureau’s move, saying that merchants who accept credit cards are punished with higher costs.
But consumer groups argue removing the rules would allow individual businesses to impose unfair charges.
Altering the rules would allow retailers to tack on extra fees, boosting the cost of a $100 purchase to as much as $103 for those using credit cards.
The poll found that 87 per cent of the respondents use credit cards and more than four out of five of them, when told of the planned fee changes, would oppose them.
Respondents to their consumer poll were told that “Canadian merchants currently pay approximately $5 billion per year as part of their overhead for services provided by credit card companies.
Get weekly money news
“If successful, an initiative from the Competition Bureau would transfer the responsibility of paying this $5 billion from merchants to consumers in the form of surcharges on purchases made with a credit card.”
But the Competition Bureau took issue with the way the association phrased its question to consumers, calling it “fundamentally flawed and misleading.”
The bureau said it simply wants to give merchants the choice as to whether or not to levy a surcharge.
“The evidence from other jurisdictions indicates that surcharging has had a positive impact, such as increasing competition between Visa and MasterCard,” it said in an emailed response Thursday.
“This has resulted in lower credit card fees for merchants and ultimately, lower prices for consumers.”
Dan Kelly of the Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses said he’s not surprised by the polling results, but added consumers may be shocked to learn they’re already paying for such fees.
“I would imagine that very few consumers would want to pay extra fees on anything, so that makes total sense,” Kelly, senior vice-president of legislative affairs at CFIB, said of the poll results.
“What consumers, of course, don’t know is they’re paying these fees anyway. Right now they’re paying these fees …. embedded in the cost of everything they purchase. They’re buried in the cost of service so people feel better about it.”
- Alberta tweaks carbon capture incentive program to allow grants during construction
- ‘Cash is king’: Why money is a popular holiday present for many Canadians
- Rancher says Alberta well cleanup fund a positive step — but litany of concerns remain
- What makes the Anthropic IPO so significant, and what is the ‘god share’?
However, he added, small businesses are particularly hurt by the processing fees, which have jumped by 30 to 40 per cent in the past few years.
“It’s virtually impossible for a merchant to say no to Visa and MasterCard acceptance and therefore they’re forced to pay these higher fees,” he said.
“The merchant can take it on the chin for a while, but ultimately (the charges) get embedded in everything that Canadians buy.”
The poll, which gathered responses from 1,000 Canadians, was conducted for the association by Angus Reid between Sept. 12 and 13.
The case against credit card companies Visa and MasterCard is slated to be heard at the quasi-judicial Competition Tribunal in April.
The bureau also takes issue with credit card policies that allegedly prevent retailers from encouraging consumers to use other payment options like cash or debit. But Visa said it has no such policy and does nothing to discourage retailers from offering discounts for using another payment method.
It also opposes a requirement that merchants must accept all credit cards offered by a company, including premium cards that carry higher fees for acceptance.
The consumers association poll also suggested that four-in-five Canadians are opposed to merchants being able to reject a payment by credit card.
Visa Canada said Thursday the results of the poll indicate that an “alarming” number of Canadians are unaware of the proposed changes. It added that the study confirms its position that consumers don’t want to be charged for preferring a certain type of payment.
“Visa’s ‘no surcharging’ policy was created specifically to protect consumers from merchants who seek to impose check out fees and penalize consumers who choose the convenience, security and reliability of Visa over cash and cheques,” it said in a statement.
“Visa believes that surcharging is harmful to cardholders and unfairly shifts the reasonable costs associated with merchant acceptance of electronic payments onto the backs of consumers.”
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.