TORONTO – Canada’s largest bank has learned it needs a “very clear line of sight” on whether acquisitions can make good profits before it makes a major purchase, the bank’s chief executive said Wednesday.
Royal Bank (TSX:RY) bought more than 400 retail bank branches in states like Florida, Alabama and Georgia over the past decade, but agreed recently to sell them at a $1.57 billion loss.
“Lessons learned, I think the extent that those investments are made, you want to make sure that you’ve got a very clear line of sight in terms of the ability to generate a positive return on the capital deployed,” CEO Gord Nixon told a Canadian banking industry conference in Toronto.
Nixon said RBC’s foray into the United States failed because it was operating in a “challenged” part of the country, in states where customers were hit hard by unemployment and a tanking real estate market.
He also said several banks in the region required government bailouts to stay afloat, citing competitors Regions Financial Corp. of Alabama and SunTrust of Atlanta. North Carolina-based competitor Wachovia bank was sold to Wells Fargo.
Get weekly money news
Nixon said RBC decided to sell its U.S. retail banking operations because it would have had to keep pumping more money into a business that just wasn’t bringing in enough returns.
“In terms of lessons learned I think it’s very important that investments that are made have the scale and critical mass sufficient to generate reasonable rates of return in their context,” Nixon said.
Meanwhile, CIBC chief executive Gerry McCaughey said one thing that is hard to predict is whether non-traditional competition to its mobile banking application for smartphones will take off.
Earlier this week, Rogers Communications Inc. (TSX:RCI.B) announced it wants to expand beyond the telecom business by starting up a bank that would focus on credit and payment services. Some suggest that Rogers may be positioning itself to become a leader in mobile money transfers.
McCaughey, who was asked about non-traditional players like Walmart and PayPal offering money transfers, said it’s hard to tell whether smartphone applications will be “disruptive” or “additive” to the marketplace.
McCaughey said it is hard to predict where mobile money transfers are going in terms of profitability, but the bank is trying to keep up with developments and make sure that it responds to change.
In early 2010, CIBC was the first major Canadian bank with a mobile banking applications for the Apple iPhone and Research In Motion’s BlackBerry smartphones – moves that have been matched by several other banks.
“It isn’t that any one item that we introduced is going to be a game changer, it’s that we’re trying to make sure that we’re introducing these items and that we’re on top of this so that we understand how the business is affected,” he said.
He said online banking from personal computers was once a new technology but is now widely used.
“It became a widely distributed, very common way of doing business which you had to do in order to stay in business, but it didn’t actually make more money. It facilitated a large scale of transactions at a low cost.”
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.