As the war of words escalates over the possible benefits and drawbacks of BHP Billiton’s hostile takeover bid for PotashCorp, an executive promised that BHP would bring new opportunities to Saskatchewan, including 300 head office jobs.
Graham Kerr, president of BHP’s diamond and specialty products business, reiterated a promise to locate its global potash headquarters in the province if its US$38.6-billion offer for PotashCorp (TSX:POT) is successful.
This means the head of BHP’s potash operations – a position currently held by Kerr – plus its chief financial officer, chief legal counsel, vice-president of human resources and 300 other people will be moved to Saskatoon, he said.
Currently, many of PotashCorp’s management jobs are located in Chicago.
"We have heard a lot of commentary lately about the net benefit to Canada and to Saskatchewan. To us, this means creating new opportunity – opportunity that the status quo does not currently offer," Kerr said in a speech Tuesday to the Regina and District Chamber of Commerce.
If it acquires PotashCorp, BHP would bring several benefits to the province, including "a head office and decision making returned to Saskatchewan, a commitment to employees and local suppliers, increased community investments and a greater share of the world potash market for Saskatchewan," Kerr said.
"We are in Saskatchewan to stay, we are in it for the long-term, and we believe passionately that together we can create opportunities that do not currently exist today," he added.
The federal government is tasked with determining whether the takeover would be of net benefit to Canadians before it can be approved. The Conference Board of Canada released a report Monday that found a BHP takeover would take a bite out of the province’s coffers, but would have few other negative effects.
"We were happy to participate with contributions to the Conference Board and we welcome the endorsements of us as a good owner of the business," Kerr said.
But PotashCorp said Tuesday the report was too optimistic, arguing that it underestimates just how much government revenue would be lost if the mining giant succeeds.
The Conference Board study, done for the Saskatchewan government, found the province could lose as much as C$5.7 billion in taxes and royalties if a successful bidder chose to run PotashCorp’s operations at full tilt, a move that would depress prices for the mineral used in fertilizer and take a bite out of the province’s royalties.
But the study also said it’s unlikely that BHP would do this "because it would not be the best way to maximize the return on their investment."
However, PotashCorp questioned that assumption, saying BHP has already indicated otherwise.
"The report chose to assume that BHP would not operate full out in direct contradiction of previous BHP public statements," PotashCorp said in a statement Tuesday.
BHP chief executive Marius Kloppers has hinted that the company might pull out of Canpotex, the potash export cartel which sets local production levels to control pricing, if it acquires PotashCorp.
This would allow the company to run its operations at full capacity, lowering potash prices and, in turn, the province’s royalty revenues.
Whether or not BHP decided to run its operations at full capacity, the company would be able to take advantage of favourable tax preferences which would also hurt the province’s revenues, the report found.
This is because BHP would be able to write off the cost of building its Jansen potash project, currently under development, against income generated by PotashCorp’s properties – a move that would cost Saskatchewan at least $2 billion in tax revenue, the report said.
But Jack Mintz, director of the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary, said the report was too pessimistic, if anything, and didn’t take into account "dynamic behaviour" that could offset the lower revenues.
"If you allow these (tax) deductions to be used more quickly, that lowers the cost of capital for the Jansen project, so that should actually be a boost to investment and a boost to production, which would mean more royalties to be paid, and there was no analysis of that," Mintz said.
PotashCorp encouraged the province to remain open to competing bids, as long as the bidders commit to remaining in Canpotex – jointly owned by PotashCorp, Agrium Inc. (TSX:AGU), and Mosaic Co. (NYSE:MOS) – and honour the company’s current growth strategy.
The caveat that any suitor agree to remain in Canpotex would appear to disqualify China’s state-owned Sinochem, which has previously been tapped as the most likely alternative to a BHP-led takeover. China is interested in securing a cheap supply of potash for its growing agriculture industry, and the Conference Board said Sinochem would be more likely than BHP to pull out of Canpotex in order to keep prices low.
The Saskatchewan government will consider the report’s findings before it provides its views on the takeover offer to Ottawa, which has said it will complete its review by Nov. 3.
PotashCorp has said that BHP’s US$130-per-share bid undervalues the company. CEO Bill Doyle has predicted that other bidders would come forward but so far no white knight has emerged.
In an attempt to access more information on BHP’s intentions, PotashCorp is suing the international company in a U.S. court for allegedly misleading investors on the key facts of its takeover bid. The two companies have been firing legal salvos back and forth for the better part of two weeks, with BHP asking the court to throw out the lawsuit on the grounds that the Canadian company offers "only implausible, uncorroborated and largely irrelevant speculation."
Meanwhile, PotashCorp has asked the court to protect it against a request by BHP for "confidential strategic information," while BHP argued in a filing Tuesday that the information it has requested is directly related to PotashCorp’s original lawsuit and BHP requires it to adequately defend itself.
Shares in Potash Corp. of Saskatchewan closed down $2.30 at $145.40 Tuesday on the Toronto Stock Exchange.
With files from CJME
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.