Advertisement

Young couple found guilty of ICBC fraud

A young Lower Mainland couple has been found guilty of defrauding ICBC by falsely reporting the theft of a luxury vehicle.

In October 2007, Francois Deschenes, 27, and Christa Plomp, 26, reported to ICBC that their leased Mercedes Benz C280 had been stolen.

They claimed that they had parked the vehicle on West 1st Avenue in Vancouver and had gone to Granville Island, where they had something to eat and attended a play.

When they returned to the luxury sedan, it was gone, they said.

Because the vehicle’s mileage was near the mileage cap on their lease agreement, the claim was flagged as being suspicious, but was eventually paid out.

About $59,000 was paid to Mercedes, with $21,000 being forwarded to the couple for their lease payments to date.

In May 2008, the vehicle was recovered by RCMP when an Aldergrove man who had rented a garage for the storage of the Mercedes came forward to police.

Eric Mailhot testified that Deschenes, a former salesman for Shaw, and his girlfriend Plomp, a web-chat hostess, had dropped off the vehicle for storage and had communicated with him a number of times by email.

When Deschenes showed up later to pick up the vehicle, he did not have the car keys and the vehicle remained in storage.

At trial, Deschenes claimed that opportunistic thieves had stolen the Mercedes and taken it to the garage.

He denied that he’d stored the vehicle and claimed that Mailhot had fabricated the story about the emails and had gleaned information from Facebook.

But in her reasons for judgment released Wednesday, B.C. Supreme Court Madam Justice Carol Ross said Mailhot’s evidence was credible and reliable.

She said that she had not been given a favorable impression of either of the accused.

“My impression is that their evidence was exaggerated and contrived,” she said.

The judge noted that when it was recovered, the stolen vehicle showed no signs of damage or forced entry and the accused were the only people with keys to the vehicle.

“It makes no sense that sophisticated thieves would abandon a vehicle for six months,” she added.

“I do not believe the evidence of either of the accused.”

The judge ordered a pre-sentence report be prepared for the accused, who remain on bail. A sentencing hearing is scheduled for Oct. 13.

ICBC spokesman Mark Jan Vrem said he was not familiar with the specific case but noted that those steal from ICBC are in fact stealing from its customers.

“We are dedicated to protecting our customers and their premium dollars against fraud. We will not sit back and simply pass the cost of fraud on to our customers.”

Vrem said the public can help fight fraud by calling ICBC’s fraud tips line at 604-661-6844 or 1-800-661-6844, toll free from anywhere in the province. Callers can remain anonymous, he said.

kfraser@theprovince.com

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices