Smith rejects accusations her Alberta sovereignty bill is undemocratic power grab

Click to play video: 'Feds ‘not looking for a fight’ over Alberta’s sovereignty act'
Feds ‘not looking for a fight’ over Alberta’s sovereignty act
WATCH: Critics are raising red flags about Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's controversial “Alberta Sovereignty Within a United Canada Act,” which is aimed at standing up to the federal government. Mercedes Stephenson explains the concerns, and how Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is responding to the bill – Nov 30, 2022

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is rejecting accusations that a bill granting her and her cabinet sweeping powers to rewrite laws while bypassing the legislature is an undemocratic, dangerous power grab.

“All Albertans expect their elected officials to stand up for Alberta, no question,” Opposition NDP Leader Rachel Notley told Smith during question period Wednesday.

“But yesterday we learned the premier’s approach on sovereignty is not that, but rather a full-throated power grab from Albertans.

“She’s granting herself the ability to write laws in secret behind closed doors, no reviews, no checks, no balances. Just an unprecedented abuse of authority.”

READ MORE: Alberta sovereignty act damaging to business: Calgary Chamber of Commerce

Not so, said Smith. She said the legislature is still in charge.

Story continues below advertisement

“Every decision that is going to be made has to first get the validation from this assembly,” said Smith.

“This assembly will pass a motion, and it will give the direction to cabinet. It will always be the direction of the members (from which) we will make decisions in cabinet.”

Click to play video: 'Concern, confusion over scope of sovereignty act powers'
Concern, confusion over scope of sovereignty act powers

Smith made the comments a day after she introduced her first bill as Alberta’s new premier, fulfilling a promise she made in the recent United Conservative Party leadership campaign to bring in legislation granting Alberta the power to reject federal laws and policies deemed to be interfering in provincial jurisdiction.

Breaking news from Canada and around the world sent to your email, as it happens.

The bill, titled the Alberta Sovereignty Within a United Canada Act, would give Smith’s cabinet the power to decide which federal laws, programs and policies — or potential federal initiatives — are unconstitutional and need to be challenged.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: Ottawa ‘not looking for a fight’ over Alberta sovereignty bill, Trudeau says

They would then be granted sweeping authority usually reserved for public emergencies to meet the threat.

Cabinet would be allowed to rewrite bills they deem necessary to meet the harm being done to Alberta.

They would also be given the power to direct any provincial agency, municipality, school board, health region or municipal police force and others to not enforce federal laws.

Click to play video: 'NDP calls Alberta’s sovereignty act a ‘threat to our healthcare system’'
NDP calls Alberta’s sovereignty act a ‘threat to our healthcare system’

The bill also states that before cabinet can act using such extraordinary powers, the legislature would first have to pass a special resolution that spelled out the nature of the federal harm and the recommended remedies.

It is this legislature oversight Smith said would keep cabinet on the straight and narrow.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: Alberta sovereignty act: Municipalities, local police could get provincial directives

However, the bill does not stipulate cabinet must follow the specific direction of the legislature. Instead, it says cabinet “should consider” using the remedies spelled out in the resolution.

When it comes to the extraordinary measures, the bill says cabinet is free to carry out whatever it deems “necessary or advisable” to meet the threat.

Click to play video: 'Trudeau says feds looking at Alberta sovereignty act ‘very, very closely’'
Trudeau says feds looking at Alberta sovereignty act ‘very, very closely’

Administrative law professor Martin Olszynski, who has written on the sovereignty bill since Smith first proposed it in the spring, said if the government truly wanted to make sure cabinet had to directly and explicitly follow the wishes of the legislature, it should have made that clear in the bill — but it didn’t.

“There’s lots of room here for (cabinet) to exercise discretion,” said Olszysnki in an interview.

Story continues below advertisement

“What they’re asking is for Albertans to take them on faith that they will exercise (these powers) in a restraining manner when they can’t even bring themselves to bind themselves using the language of the act.”

Olszysnki and other constitutional experts have criticized the bill as constitutionally questionable and a major overreach of provincial authority.

Smith defended the bill after it was introduced Tuesday, saying Alberta has tried less confrontational measures to no effect and that the federal government needs “a push.”

Click to play video: '‘She wanted to deliver something that was radical’: Constitutional law expert on Alberta sovereignty act'
‘She wanted to deliver something that was radical’: Constitutional law expert on Alberta sovereignty act

Sponsored content