OTTAWA – This summer, 75 MPs will become eligible for what critics call "the most lucrative plan in the country" – their government pension.
In two weeks, on June 28, the group dubbed "Class of ’04" – after the year they were elected – will have served the requisite six years in Parliament to qualify for pension payments that kick in at age 55.
The group includes NDP Leader Jack Layton, embattled former Status of Women Minister Helena Guergis, Liberal MPs Mark Holland and Ujjal Dosanjh, and Ted Menzies, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Finance, among 70 others.
At a minimum, the pension would give them at least $25,000 a year based on the minimum MP salary that now stands at $157,731. Others who work as cabinet ministers or lead a party, for example, will get more because they can make over $210,000 – up to $75,516 on top of the basic salary.
"We have long advocated that the MP pension plan requires reform because it’s so lucrative. It’s the most lucrative plan in the country by far," said Kevin Gaudet, the federal director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
What makes it ironic, he said, is that Finance Minister Jim Flaherty has agreed to explore raising Canada Pension Plan contributions.
"This whole reform, of course, excludes the richest fat cats or members of Parliament. It’s an important failure to lead by example, their failure to address their own pension plan," said Gaudet, who will announce specific MP pension sums on Parliament Hill on Tuesday.
The MP pension is calculated using a formula that, at its most basic, consists of three per cent a year of the average income of an MP’s best five consecutive years of service, multiplied by the years of service. MPs are required to make monthly pension contributions of seven per cent of their salaries.
"You have to work your whole life to get half that in the CPP," said Gaudet.
By contrast, only 38 per cent of Canadian workers have a workplace pension plan, and the average amount held in RRSPs by those aged 55 to 64 is estimated at about $55,000, according to an April report from the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.
"There is now widespread concern that unless changes are made, a significant number of workers will reach retirement age without sufficient income to support themselves," read the report.
Some politicians deflected criticism by pointing out that the pension system itself needs to change.
"Our goal right now is to get all Canadians access to adequate pensions. And we’ve been pressing the government to bring in a significant increase to the Canada Pension Plan, so that every Canadian can have retirement security," said Layton.
He added that his pension is public.
"It’s available, I hope that people will have a look at it and see what they think about it," he said.
Another inductee into this year’s pension group, Minister of International Trade Peter Van Loan, conceded that six-year MPs receive "a generous pension plan," but they also pay a "great deal" into it.
"I personally come from a background where in the private sector I would not have had a pension, so I haven’t had a great deal of interest in the pension plan. But I can understand why many Canadians do," he said.
Liberal MP John McCallum, who was first elected in 2000, said the point of pension reform is not to criticize politicians but to improve the lot of Canadians.
"The solution doesn’t really lie in pulling people down. The solution lies in putting funding in new thinking, in new policies, to pull people up, those who don’t have adequate pensions. Certainly MPs are not in that category, but there’s a growing number of Canadians who face inadequate retirement income," he said.
Erin Weir, an economist at United Steelworkers union, agrees that little will be achieved by pouncing on politicians.
"We should look at the MP pension plan as a model and use it to improve pension coverage for all Canadians, and I think that expanding the Canada Pension Plan would be one step in that direction," he said.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.