Advertisement

Top soldier says firing general was right thing to do

OTTAWA – Canada’s top soldier on Wednesday defended the decision to remove Brig.-Gen. Daniel Menard, accused of sexual misconduct, from leading Canadian forces in Afghanistan just before a major offensive was planned for the Kandahar region.

Gen. Walt Natynczyk said Menard’s firing is a matter of enforcing strong discipline in the Armed Forces and applying the same standards to everyone.

"We’ve sent other people home for the same thing," Natynczyk, chief of defence staff, told reporters.

Menard, whose wife is also in the military, was fired last weekend and recalled to Canada by Lt.-Gen. Marc Lessard, commander of all Canadian troops overseas, on grounds he had an inappropriate relationship with a female member of the force in theatre.

Natynczyk asserted "we were respectful" of Menard’s wife and children in handling the situation.

"We have pretty clear policies to ensure a high level of discipline within the entire contingent," Natynczyk said after delivering a speech at a military trade show. "We’re on duty 24 hours a day and you never know what could occur . . . When we put people in harm’s way we have to insist on a high level of discipline no matter what we’re doing."

He said Menard, who commanded 2,800 Canadian military personnel in Afghanistan, retains his rank while an investigation is underway. Menard, 42, could be stripped of his rank and potentially face a court martial.

"We will wait for the investigation," Natynczyk said.

Responding to a question of whether Menard’s treatment is demoralizing or disruptive to troops in Afghanistan, Natynczyk said it encouraged confidence in the way the military conducts business. "You know for the soldiers on the ground they’ll acknowledge it but also acknowledge the fact that we’ve sent other people home for the same thing, you know, and we’re holding everyone to the same standard," he said.

"We hold our leaders to a high standard," Natynczyk said.

Natynczyk said he supports Lessard’s decision and has "absolute confidence" in Brig.-Gen. Jon Vance, Menard’s predecessor in Afghanistan who has resumed command in Afghanistan until the end of September. American and NATO commanders understand the situation, know Vance and also have absolute confidence in him, he added.

Menard had been named to lead a critical NATO campaign against the Taliban in Kandahar.

He is under investigation by the military’s police’s National Investigation Service, which handles "serious and sensitive service and criminal matters" for the forces and has the right to lay charges.

"Sexual activity or any other form of intimate contact in any context," is strictly forbidden for Canadian troops in Afghanistan, according to standing orders on personal relationships that every soldier receives before deploying to South Asia.

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices