Advertisement

Que. medical school grads have much less debt and stress, study finds

OTTAWA – Medical schools in Canada should take a cue from Quebec where graduates complete their education with far less debt and stress, according to a new study that suggests the high cost of med school may be putting the health of Canadians at risk.

The study, published Tuesday in the journal Medical Education, found doctors-in-training across much of Canada graduate with an average of $90,000 in debt.

The study – which was supported by faculty members at St. Michael’s Hospital and the University of Toronto and is based on the responses of some 7,624 medical school students surveyed in 2001 and 2007 – highlighted several financial differences between Quebec medical programs and those elsewhere in Canada.

For one thing, the study found provincial subsidies have helped keep tuition fees substantially lower in Quebec than in the rest of Canada. For example, tuition fees for the first year of medical school at the University of Toronto jumped to more than $18,000 in 2007 from just over $3,000 in 1994. By contrast, fees at the University of Montreal rose to about $3,500 from $2,200 during the same time period.

The study also found that medical students outside Quebec tend to come from wealthier, more highly educated, urban backgrounds and are more likely to be white, Chinese or South Asian, than black or aboriginal.

In Quebec, where the average medical student graduates with a much smaller debt load – about $30,000 on average – student backgrounds tend to be more varied, the study found.

In 2007, about 15 per cent of medical students across Canada reported being very or extremely stressed about their financial situation compared to less than 5.4 per cent of Quebec med students who reported the same.

It’s a concern, say researchers, as demographics and doctor shortages are interrelated.

"Students from lower-income visible minority and rural backgrounds are more likely to treat disadvantaged patients and to practise in areas where doctor shortages are especially severe," said the study led by Dr. Shaheed Merani, a medical student at the University of Alberta.

"That individuals from particular groups are markedly under-represented in the medical student population suggests that individuals from these groups probably face significant barriers to entering medical school."

Increased indebtedness and financial stress could also have an adverse impact on the areas of medicine students choose to pursue, Merani said. They may avoid primary care, geriatrics and academic medicine, for example, choosing better paying jobs in dermatology and plastic surgery instead.

"It kind of makes sense that if you have a high debt load, you may be swayed to practise either in a location that’s higher paying or to practise in a specialty that’s higher paying," he said, cautioning the evidence is not conclusive.

"The counter argument to that is that those specialties also require a longer training window."

Merani suggested non-repayable bursaries and the fact that Quebec students can enter medical school after Cegep – on average about three years earlier than other Canadians who must first complete an undergraduate degree – are some of the factors likely to impact student debt.

Ijab Khanafer of the Canadian Federation of Medical Students said the study confirms what medical students have felt for some time and is urging provincial governments and universities to take note.

"We’re very aware that it’s a tough economic time for universities and provincial governments alike," she said. "What we would like is an exploration of what has worked in Quebec and how this could be applied in other provinces."

Khanafer hopes the study will spark discussions about how to improve financial aid for students from rural and low income backgrounds as well as mentorship and recruitment support so such students cannot only apply and get into medical programs but also succeed once they’re there.

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices