Harper ‘very concerned’ over Brazil spy claims
Video: Brazil’s president is outraged over reports Canada has been spying on her government and PM Harper said there’s reason to be concerned. Jennifer Madigan reports.
BALI, Indonesia – Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he’s “very concerned” about reports that Canada’s top-secret electronic spy agency is doing industrial espionage in Brazil.
Harper said Canadian officials are “reaching out very proactively” to their counterparts in Brazil.
Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff is accusing the Ottawa-based Communications Security Establishment Canada of mounting a sophisticated spy operation against her country’s ministry of mines and energy.
Video: Harper addresses Brazil spying claims as APEC summit wraps. Mike Le Couteur reports.
The claim is based on documents leaked to Brazilian media by Edward Snowden, a former contractor with the National Security Agency – the American counterpart of Canada’s CSE.
Speaking at the Asia Pacific leaders summit in Bali, Harper said there is a commissioner of the spy agency who audits the organization to ensure it operates within Canadian law and added that his the government will be doing what he called “appropriate follow-up.”
The Prime Minister’s Office initially dismissed the reports of the Brazilian spying by saying it never comments on matters of national security. However the claims relate specifically to economic espionage and cannot be so easily brushed aside.
Brazil’s Foreign Minister Luiz Alberto Figueiredo summoned the Canadian ambassador in the capital of Brasilia on Monday to “transmit the indignation of the Brazilian government and demand explanations,” said a statement from the Foreign Ministry.
The statement said Figueiredo expressed “the government’s repudiation of this serious and unacceptable violation of national sovereignty and the rights of people and companies.”
The CSEC, headquartered in Ottawa, monitors foreign computer, satellite, radio and telephone traffic for intelligence of interest to Canada.
But it has never been known as a hub of economic intelligence gathering.
Harper said he’ll be checking to see if the agency acted within the law.
“We do have a commissioner of the Canadian Security Establishment,” said the prime minister.
“That commissioner does surveillance and audits the organization to make sure its operating within Canadian law. As I say, we are concerned and we will do appropriate followup.”
The damaging allegations threaten to turn into a major diplomatic feud between the emerging South American economic powerhouse and Canada, which hopes to extend trade ties in the region.
In Montreal, Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau said his party will introduce legislation next week that would, if passed, allow a parliamentary committee to monitor national security activities.
“It’s a principle that’s well established in democracies around the world,” Trudeau said. “The committee would be subjected to rules that would allow it to ensure that our security agencies are protecting us without abusing their powers.”
Trudeau called the revelations about Canada’s activities in Brazil “troubling” and slammed Harper’s claim that he knew nothing of what CSEC had been doing.
“This is a prime minister who controls everything – whether it’s in his office or his government,” he said.
“If it’s true that he didn’t know what was going on, that’s disappointing. That suggests a lack of supervision of our agencies.”
With files from Julien Arsenault in Montreal
© 2013 The Canadian Press