Advertisement

Elon Musk wants Twitter to be ‘the platform for free speech.’ What about misinformation?

Click to play video: 'Elon Musk offers to buy Twitter for US$41 billion' Elon Musk offers to buy Twitter for US$41 billion
WATCH: Elon Musk offers to buy Twitter for US$41 billion – Apr 14, 2022

Elon Musk wants to buy Twitter so he can unleash its full potential as an arena for free speech, he says — but depending on how he approaches that, researchers warn he could create an environment where misinformation thrives.

Musk’s move to buy Twitter became public in an SEC filing on Thursday, where the billionaire electric vehicle manufacturer laid out his vision for the platform.

Read more: Elon Musk offers to buy Twitter for US$43 billion

“No guidelines (for) your speech on social media can be a cause of concern, especially with with the kinds of issues that we’re seeing today,” said Mary Blankenship, a University of Nevada researcher who looks at how misinformation spreads through Twitter.

She pointed to COVID-19 as an example.

Story continues below advertisement

“We can see how that kind of misinformation really seeps into people’s perception of the medical dangers, and can actually lead to (them) either being infected or even death.”

Read more: The great COVID-19 infodemic: How disinformation networks are radicalizing Canadians

Musk offered to buy 100 per cent of Twitter for US$54.20 per share “in cash.” That would work out to about US$43 billion for the entire purchase — a total Musk told a TED2022 conference he could “technically afford.”

He says he hopes to transform the platform into “an inclusive arena for free speech.”

“Twitter has become kind of the de facto town square,” Musk said.

“It’s just really important that people have the reality and the perception that they’re able to speak freely within the bounds of the law.”

Click to play video: 'The David and Goliath fight against online conspiracies' The David and Goliath fight against online conspiracies
The David and Goliath fight against online conspiracies – Apr 9, 2022

How we define the bounds of the law, however, is where things get tricky.

Story continues below advertisement

Different countries have different laws regarding speech on social media or elsewhere. For example, the U.S. has a First Amendment right to free speech. Canada has a right to freedom of expression but it is subject to far more limits.

On top of that, Twitter, as it stands now, doesn’t do a great job when it comes to shutting down false narratives, according to misinformation experts.

“There really isn’t a lot of censorship,” said Carmen Celestini, an adjunct professor at the University of Waterloo.

Read more: Twitter crackdown on COVID-19 vaccine misinformation will see repeat offenders removed

“I think they’ve done a really good job at trying to limit disinformation, especially stuff about COVID, conspiracy theories, everything like that — but there is a lot of seeping of that information, already, on Twitter.”

Click to play video: 'Coronavirus searches trend on Twitter as experts recommend sticking to credible sources' Coronavirus searches trend on Twitter as experts recommend sticking to credible sources
Coronavirus searches trend on Twitter as experts recommend sticking to credible sources – Mar 11, 2020

Blankenship agreed — propaganda and disinformation “still manages to seep through” on the platform.

Story continues below advertisement

“Now, imagine if you didn’t have any of the constraints imposed by social media sites, just how rampant disinformation and misinformation and propaganda is going to be,” she said.

Falsehoods are 70 per cent more likely to be retweeted on Twitter than facts, according to a 2018 study published by professors from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Media Lab.

Falsehoods also reach their first 1,500 people six times faster, they found.

Read more: ‘Freedom convoy’ forums find new focus: disinformation about Russia-Ukraine war

It’s an issue Blankenship knows all too well. She is Ukrainian, with family throughout Ukraine who feel the ramifications of misinformation every day.

“Elon Musk has stated that he wouldn’t even want to block any Russian news outlets,” Blankenship said, referring to Musk’s reluctance to bar Russian news from SpaceX’s satellite broadband company Starlink in Ukraine.

“These are news outlets that continuously call for, essentially, a genocide of the Ukrainian population.”

Russian President Vladimir Putin has used propaganda repeatedly in a bid to drum up support for his invasion of Ukraine. Between perpetuating lies about the number of neo-Nazis in Ukraine and rumours circulating about his quest to destroy alleged bioweapons labs in the country, information has become another tool of warfare in this conflict.

Story continues below advertisement
Click to play video: 'Countering online misinformation through the Ukraine war' Countering online misinformation through the Ukraine war
Countering online misinformation through the Ukraine war – Mar 14, 2022

Celestini agreed that misinformation can be “a dangerous thing.”

“It affects populism, it affects politics. It affects people’s beliefs,” she said.

If misinformation and disinformation are allowed to spread without any constraints, this impact will “absolutely” grow, Celestini said.

Global News contacted Twitter to ask what percentage of the platform’s censorship is the result of a user spreading misinformation and disinformation. Twitter would not disclose any firm figures.

Rather, the website pointed Global News toward its rules — which include bans against “hateful content’ as well as any content that threatens “civic integrity,” such as elections.

Speaking to TED2022, Musk was pressed on where he’d draw the line in terms of free speech on Twitter, should his bid to buy the platform succeed.

Story continues below advertisement

Read more: Elon Musk sued by investor for delayed disclosure of Twitter stake

He said repeatedly that any speech must fall “within the bounds of the law,” though he did not specify whose laws those would be. He also said Twitter should make its algorithm “open-source.”

There should be “no … behind the scenes of manipulation, either algorithmically or manually,” Musk said.

The self-described “free-speech absolutist” did not, however, lay out precise parameters of what he’d consider to be free speech.

Read more: Elon Musk won’t be joining Twitter’s board of directors after all

For Celestini, concerns about Musk’s Twitter takeover could themselves be characterized as a sort of misinformation — because it hasn’t happened yet, and it’s unclear whether it will go ahead.

“Don’t worry about problems you don’t have,” she said.

A majority of shareholders will have to agree to Musk’s offer, which pitches the US$54.20 share price as his “best offer,” despite the stock trading at more than US$70 per share just last year.

Twitter’s audience, Celestini added, covers a wide variety of political views — and those with extreme views are not the majority.

Story continues below advertisement

“He’s not dumb enough to spend this much money to destroy something and lose all of that money,” she said.

“So we have to take that into consideration, if he truly wanted to build a free speech zone.”

Sponsored content