Advertisement

Giant Mine widows lose appeal at Supreme Court

OTTAWA — Widows who lost their husbands in the notorious Giant Mine explosion in Yellowknife almost 20 years ago lost their bid for more than $10-million in compensation Thursday when the Supreme Court rejected their appeal.

The families were challenging a Northwest Territories Court of Appeal ruling, which had overturned an earlier decision ordering the mine’s owner, Royal Oak Ventures, and three other parties to pay $10.7-million for the wrongful death of nine miners in the fatal blast in September 1992.

The territorial government, the Canadian Auto Workers union, and Pinkerton’s, the security firm hired to guard the mine site during a nasty labour dispute, were also named in the civil suit.

The workers — hired replacements and staffers who had crossed the picket line — lost their lives in the underground explosion intentionally ignited by former miner Roger Warren, who is serving a life sentence for nine counts of second-degree murder.

The Supreme Court ruling upholds the appeal court finding the parties did not contribute to the miners’ deaths because the murders were an extreme and unforeseeable act of one person.

The decision overturned a 2004 ruling in the Northwest Territories Supreme Court, which found the parties named in the suit were negligent, to varying degrees.

Labour lawyers have closely watched the case, warning that restoring a victory for the widows could mean unions are responsible for the actions of their members during strikes.

The families, in legal arguments filed in the Supreme Court, assert the deaths were “reasonably foreseeable” and that prior to the murders, all parties had expressed concern the strike was so bitter it could lead to serious injury or loss of life.

The widows argued in a written submission to the Supreme Court the union must be held vicariously liable because “during the most menacing strike in Canadian history . . . members and officials of the striking union incited, organized, funded and participated in violence aimed at the replacement workers.”

Also, the miners working through the strike relied on the company, Pinkerton’s and the Northwest Territories government to “take reasonable steps to ensure that their workplace was safe,” the families’ legal brief said.

The nine men were killed when their underground vehicle hit a trip wire that detonated a bomb. Three of the men were replacement workers and six were union workers who had returned to the job as the strike at the underground gold mine lingered for months.

The territorial Workers’ Compensation Board filed the lawsuit in 1994 to try to recoup some money to help support the widows and their families, which included 17 children.

The 2004 ruling found Warren was 26% responsible for the tragedy while Royal Oak was 23% responsible and the Canadian Auto Workers was 22% responsible.

The decision assigned 15% of the blame to Pinkerton’s, nine per cent to the Northwest Territories government and five per cent to specific union members.

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices