Advertisement

Ontario AG releases damning report on spending scandal at eHealth

TORONTO – Ontario’s auditor general says mismanagement and lack of oversight at eHealth Ontario should fall on the shoulders of the just-resigned Liberal health minister, David Caplan.

"At the end of the day, the minister of Health has to have some accountability for it," Jim McCarter told reporters Wednesday. "It’s senior management, it’s the minister of Health."

In a highly anticipated report released Wednesday, McCarter outlined more than $1 billion in spending – much of it wasteful – at eHealth and it’s predecessor agency, Smart Systems for Health Agency.

Health officials tried to block McCarter from conducting the audit, he says – an unusual tactic that immediately sounded alarms in his mind.

"I have to be honest, delaying us is kind of like waving the red flag at a bull," he told reporters.

He only gained access to the agency after threatening senior bureaucrats he would report their actions to the legislature.

Once he did that, he said, "we got in the door the next day."

McCarter says he discovered the government’s effort to get health records online by 2015 was almost completely aimless. In fact, the Health Ministry did not develop a strategic plan for their multi-billion-dollar project until March 2009, seven years after it was begun.

"When you get a lack of oversight, you get broken rules," McCarter told reporters at a press conference Wednesday morning. "It goes together like a horse and carriage."

In his scathing report, McCarter portrays the health ministry as a body run amok with consultants.

By 2008, the eHealth program branch of the ministry had engaged 300 consultants compared to less than 30 full-time ministry employees, according to the special report.

Some of the consultants even held senior management positions.

"Consultants were not only managing other consultants but also at times had the authority to hire more consultants, sometimes from their own firm," McCarter states in the report.

The scandal, the worst in Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty’s two terms at the helm of the province, has already prompted multiple resignations, including, most recently, Health Minister David Caplan.

McGuinty said Wednesday he accepted Caplan’s resignation reluctantly and thanked him for his good work. Deb Matthews takes over for Caplan in a mini-shuffle that also brought Laurel Broten back into cabinet.

McCarter concluded taxpayers "have not received value for money for this $1 billion investment."

At eHealth, that spending included lavish executive pay as well as tens of millions in untendered contracts.

"We do not accept "urgency" or the fact that the consultants had relevant experience as valid reasons for this sole-sourcing of contracts," the report states. "Neither do we accept the contention that the procurement policies in place . . . justified the sole-sourcing."

The audit shows former eHealth CEO Sarah Kramer, who resigned in June, just four months after she was hired, showed "favouritism" in handing out tens of millions in sole-sourced contract.

Those questionable deals include a $1 million contract to an external recruiting firm which only filled five of 15 positions it was contracted to fill. No money was requested by or returned to eHealth, despite the only partial completion of the job.

Some of the controversial contracts raised Wednesday were unearthed this spring by the opposition Conservatives.

Tory leader Tim Hudak called Caplan’s resignation "long overdue."

Dr. Alan Hudson, eHealth chair, resigned from his volunteer position shortly after Kramer, was effectively exonerated from wrongdoing Wednesday.

"Although we saw no evidence that the board asked for any details on procurements, we believe that the board was under the impression, based on information provided to it, that consultants and other vendors were being procured in accordance with established policies."

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices