Marc Miller wants to improve working conditions for First Nations water operators ‘as soon as possible’

Click to play video: 'Indigenous Services minister says more needs to be done on First Nations water operator wages on reserve'
Indigenous Services minister says more needs to be done on First Nations water operator wages on reserve
Indigenous Services Minister Marc Miller addressed a question regarding whether the government had considered securing proper pay and wages for First Nations water operators on reserve, saying he acknowledged it was not fair that those on reserve earned low wages, sometimes less than half of their counterparts off reserve – Feb 24, 2021

Indigenous Services Minister Marc Miller says the Trudeau government is working on a plan to improve the pay and working conditions of water operators on First Nations, but he doesn’t know how long it will take.

Miller made the comments at a news conference on Wednesday in response to questions about a recent investigation by Global News, APTN News, the Institute for Investigative Journalism and other media organizations.

Based on in-depth interviews with 122 operators working in First Nations water treatment plants across Canada, the investigation found that more than two-thirds of the operators said they made less than the median wage of the profession in their province. More than half also said that they were on call 24 hours a day and seven days a week.

Story continues below advertisement

“It isn’t fair,” Miller said at the news conference in Ottawa.

At least a third of the water operators said in interviews that they were being paid a wage that was lower than the lowest wage for their profession in their respective province or territory, as estimated by the federal government. And about seven per cent of the water operators told the investigation they were making less than $14 an hour.

The investigation also found that the government has known for years that its policies and funding formulas are outdated and cumbersome, making it difficult for many First Nations to pay for ongoing maintenance and operations of their infrastructure, including water systems.

Graphic summarizing results of a national survey of water operators in First Nations who reported being overworked and underpaid in early 2020.

One of the water operators, Nathan Martell from the Moosomin First Nation, said he worked two jobs, including as a water operator in North Battleford, Sask., 40 kilometres to the south. He explained that he gets full benefits and is paid more for the work he does in North Battleford, but that he has chosen to continue working in his own nation at the same time.

Story continues below advertisement

“The big thing for me is, it’s our community,” Martell said. “We grew up here and my family’s from here and if they’re not getting good quality water, then that drives me … I don’t want nobody to get sick or anything to go wrong. And it’s my home. You can’t turn your back on home.”

About a hundred journalists worked on the investigation, including students from 10 different universities across the country, who conducted in-depth interviews with water operators in early 2020.

Breaking news from Canada and around the world sent to your email, as it happens.

Miller said the reporting by Global News and its partners was “excellent” and reflects what he has heard in conversations with First Nations leaders.

Click to play video: 'Indigenous Services minister says Ottawa must work with communities to get data on water-related health outcomes'
Indigenous Services minister says Ottawa must work with communities to get data on water-related health outcomes

He added that the Trudeau government has already announced plans to improve its policies in its recent fall economic statement, but Miller was unable to say when this would result in better working conditions for First Nations water operators.

Story continues below advertisement

“I don’t have that for you yet,” Miller said. “I’d like to see it as soon as possible. But it represents some policy shifts within the government — within the department that, in fairness, I have to go back and work on with the team. So we’ve acknowledged we know it exists. We know it’s unfair. We’re going to change it.”

Nathan Martell is the water operator at Moosomin First Nation. Photo taken on Moosomin First Nation, Sask., on Wednesday, Aug. 5, 2020. Matt Smith/Saskatoon StarPhoenix

This reporting was done in partnership with a consortium led by Concordia University’s Institute for Investigative Journalism that includes Global News, APTN News, the University of King’s College, L’Université du Québec à Montréal, the University of Regina School of Journalism and First Nations University of Canada Indigenous Communication Arts (INCA).

Investigative team:

Institute for Investigative Journalism reporting fellowship:

Jaida Beaudin-Herney, First Nations University of Canada

Story continues below advertisement

First Nations University of Canada

Taryn Acoose, Jaida Beaudin-Herney (IIJ Summer Fellow), Brittany Boschman, Charmaine Ermine, Danna Henderson, Krystal Lewis, Alicia Morrow, Darla Ponace, Mercedes Redman, Shayla Sayer-Brabant, Doris Wesaquate. Instructor: Patricia W. Elliott

University of Regina

Suliman Adam, Kerry Benjoe, Adam Bent, Ethan Butterfield, Jacob Carr, Dylan Earis, Morgan Esperance, Mick Favel, Libby Giesbrecht, Sayda Momtaha Habib, Theresa Kliem, Michelle Lerat, Donovan Maess, Kaitlynn Nordal, Kehinde Olalafe, Heather O’Watch, Julia Peterson, Tuuli Rantasalo, Paige Reimer, Kaitlyn Schropp, Dan Sherven, Penny Smoke, Dawson Thompson, Jasper Watrich. Instructors: Patricia W. Elliott, Trevor Grant, Layton Burton

— with files from Kaaria Quash (Concordia University), Geneviève Larochelle-Guy (L’Université du Québec à Montréal), Krystal Lewis (First Nations University of Canada), Michael Wrobel, Patti Sonntag (Institute for Investigative Journalism), Ryan Kessler (Global News), Andrea Hill (Saskatoon StarPhoenix), Priscilla Wolf (APTN News)

University of King’s College:

Nebal Snan, Emma Wilkie (Instructor: Pauline Dakin)

See the full list of “Broken Promises” series credits and more information about the consortium on the Clean Water, Broken Promises website.

Produced by the Institute for Investigative Journalism, Concordia University.

For tips on this story, please contact the reporters at


Sponsored content