Donald Marshall’s ordeal began late one night in 1971 when he and Sandy Seale, a female acquaintance, took a walk through a park in Sydney, N.S. The teenagers attempted to rob an older man named Roy Ebsary. A scuffle ensued and Seale was fatally stabbed.
Police launched an investigation that focused on Marshall. Police charged him with murder, and the 17-year-old Aboriginal was convicted and sentenced to life in prison.
He languished there until 1982, when the RCMP reviewed his case. Marshall was acquitted the following year. Ebsary was charged and convicted of manslaughter. He spent a year in jail.
In subsequent years, Marshall struggled to get compensation from provincial and federal governments.
His trials and tribulations generated a lot of interest in Canada, especially among prison reform groups.
In 1987, a royal commission began to investigate the case. Two years later, it concluded that “the criminal justice system failed Donald Marshall Jr. at virtually every turn.” The commission also determined that the police and judiciary had acted unprofessionally and incompetently, and that racism was a factor in the wrongful conviction.
The commission recommended an independent review mechanism be instituted to look into allegations of wrongful conviction.
Marshall was awarded a lifetime pension of $1.5 million in compensation.
He made headlines again in 1996 when he was convicted for illegally catching and selling eels out of season and without a license.
Three years later, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that his activities were valid under treaties between Aboriginals and the colonial government in the 1760s. The court determined that a licensing system or regulatory prohibition would infringe on that right.
Marshall was acquitted, and the high court ruled that Aboriginals in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia have the right to earn a living from hunting, fishing and gathering.
Some non-native fishermen reacted with anger, fearing for their livelihoods.
In October 1999, thousands of Aboriginal traps were destroyed in New Brunswick, triggering some violent outbursts.
In 2003, Marshall underwent an eight-hour operation to replace both his failing lungs; he had been suffering from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
Three years ago, Marshall was arrested and charged with attempted murder for allegedly attempting to run over a man with his car after a New Year’s Eve party. The charges were dropped after both men agreed to participate in a healing circle.
Marshall died on Aug. 6, 2009. He was 55.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.