Advertisement

Quebec judge declares parts of vaping legislation invalid after challenge

A man smokes an electronic cigarette in Chicago on April 23, 2014. A Quebec Superior Court judge says the province is within its rights to legislate on vaping but has declared certain sections of the law forbidding the demonstration of vaping products inside shops or specialized clinics invalid. Nam Y. Huh, File/AP The Canadian Press

Quebec is within its rights to legislate on vaping, but a provision banning demonstrations of vaping products inside shops or specialized clinics goes too far, a Quebec judge has ruled.

In a judgment released Friday, the court also invalidated another section of the provincial law prohibiting the advertising of vaping products to smokers seeking to kick their habit.

READ MORE: Canadian vaping industry challenging Quebec law

A legal challenge was brought by an association representing Quebec vape shops and the Canadian Vaping Association.

They argued that parts of the Tobacco Control Act adopted by the Quebec government in 2015 violated their fundamental rights, notably freedom of expression.

Justice Daniel Dumais has suspended his ruling for six months to allow lawmakers to rewrite the problematic sections of the province’s tobacco law to make them valid.

Story continues below advertisement

The Quebec association had also argued the province had overstepped its legislative authority by including vaping products.

Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday.

Get weekly health news

Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

WATCH: Health organizations call for stricter rules on vaping

Click to play video: 'Health organizations call for stricter rules on vaping'
Health organizations call for stricter rules on vaping

However, Dumais, who heard arguments province’s Superior Court over 10 days last December, ruled Quebec had a right to legislate on the issue.

“Overall, the law is constitutional,” Dumais wrote in a lengthy decision dated Friday. “Quebec has jurisdiction to legislate as it has done. The Quebec legislature has jurisdiction and could validly pass the contested laws.”

The wide-ranging law was designed in part to put the popular e-cigarette on the same footing as other tobacco products and anti-tobacco groups argued that e-cigarettes needed to be subjected to regulations to prevent youth from using it.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE:New Health Canada campaign warns youth about risks of vaping

But the judge agreed to strike down two sections of the law that prohibited the demonstration of vaping products inside specialty shops and smoking cessation clinics.

The Canadian association had argued those sections of the law violated the right to integrity and personal security as well as freedom of expression. The judge also struck down sections of the law that prevent vaping from being advertised to smokers who aim to stop smoking, ruling it violates freedom of expression.

The judge wrote that while the provisions take into account the well being of non-smokers, it seemed to forget the rest of the population — including those smokers who are looking to quit.

“The problem with the current restrictions is that the public — particularly smokers — do not distinguish between smoking and vaping,” the judge wrote. “They must be permitted to know the difference. Rather than silence, it is sometimes necessary to educate and let people know that vaping exists first and foremost for smokers.”

Sponsored content

AdChoices