OTTAWA – An independent commission will organize federal leaders’ debates for the next election to take the planning out of back rooms where political parties try to design the debates for their own advantage, Democratic Institutions Minister Karina Gould announced Tuesday.
The plan went over like a lead balloon with the Official Opposition, who say the plan is evidence of election rigging.
The commission will organize two leaders’ debates for the 2019 election – one in each official language – and will ensure discussions are accessible to all Canadians on various communication platforms, Gould said outside the House of Commons.
“What this whole thing is about is ensuring that this is done in a public, transparent way and to ensure that the public interest is at the centre, and not partisan interest,” Gould said.
The government has nominated former governor general David Johnston to lead the commission, she added. He is planning to appear before a Commons committee to speak with MPs about the work.
“I hope they (MPs) engage in good faith and have a productive conversation with him because I think as most Canadians will agree, he is absolutely an impartial, independent individual who has the best interest of Canadians at heart,” she said.
WATCH: Former Russian troll warns Canada should be ‘on guard’ ahead of 2019 election
However, Conservative democratic institutions critic Stephanie Kusie said that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is trying to control the debate process and ensure it is set up in the “best way possible to support the government.”
She pointed to the number of debates, just two, and format as evidence to support this case.
“Essentially what this is doing, this is silencing Canadians,” she said.
The commission will have to report to Parliament following the 2019 debates with recommendations for a permanent commission, Gould said Tuesday. In the United States, debates among presidential candidates are organized by a commission with members from both the Republican and Democratic parties.
NDP democratic reform critic Nathan Cullen also had questions, noting a House of Commons committee recommended the commissioner be selected by all registered parties and the Liberals didn’t do that.
He also raised questions about the $5.5-million budget, noting he would like to see a breakdown. Debates just aren’t that expensive, he said.
“It’s podiums,” he said. “It’s glasses of water.”
During the 2015 election campaign Justin Trudeau promised to create an arm’s-length body to organize future leaders’ debates.
Until that election, Canadian voters had traditionally had at least two opportunities during the campaign to assess party leaders in televised debates – one in French, one in English – organized by a consortium of broadcasters.
WATCH: Federal Conservatives map out plan for 2019 election
The formats of the debates and which leaders would be invited was negotiated among the consortium members and the parties and each would try to advance its own interests.
Debate over the debates grew in 2015 when the Conservatives announced that Stephen Harper, prime minister at the time, would not participate in consortium-organized debates.
A number of other debates organized by a variety of media outlets were held instead, but they reached much smaller audiences. Different rules set by different organizers meant Green Party Leader Elizabeth May was in two televised debates but excluded from three others.
WATCH: How Maxime Bernier’s resignation could affect the Conservatives
May said Tuesday that the Liberals have made it clear her party will indeed be included in the 2019 debate and called Johnston an “inspired choice” and one Canadians can trust to be “above the political fray.”
Gould said leaders of political parties that meet two of the following three criteria will be included:
- have a MP at the time the election is called
- intend to run candidates in at least 90 per cent of electoral districts
- have either obtained four per cent of the vote in a previous election or have a “legitimate” chance to win seats in the upcoming election
Comments