Manitoba dairy farmers concerned over NAFTA replacement deal

Dairy farmers of Manitoba worry the new trade deal will put a damper on their profitability
WATCH: Dave Wiens, president of Manitoba Dairy Farmers, says the trade agreement will be especially hard for young farmers just staring out.

Amid word that a renegotiated trade pact between Canada, the U.S. and Mexico will undercut Canada’s dairy industry, Manitoba dairy farmers say the the deal puts a damper on plans for future growth.

READ MORE: Canadian dairy farmers slam new trade agreement, say it will have ‘dramatic impact’

Dairy Farmers of Canada say the newly minted U.S.-Mexico-Canada Trade Agreement, or USMCA, will grant greater market access to the domestic dairy market and eliminate competitive dairy classes, which the group says will shrink the Canadian industry.

Here’s what Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said of the deal:

Bothwell Cheese executive vice president Wally Smith says he is concerned about what increased market access will look like.

“We are still trying to determine exactly what the economic implications of that would be for our company,” Smith said. “This milk is locally sourced from Manitoba dairy farmers, and we are very proud of the product we provide the Canadian marketplace.”

Story continues below advertisement

WATCH: Global’s Amber McGuckin breaks down affects the NAFTA replacement deal will have in our province

NAFTA replacement deal a damper on Manitoba dairy producers, but a win for shoppers
NAFTA replacement deal a damper on Manitoba dairy producers, but a win for shoppers

Details on the deal remained sparse, but U.S. administration officials say it provides increased access to Canada’s dairy market for U.S. producers and limits the American impact on Canada’s controversial supply management system for dairy and poultry products.

“It’s going to be very critical to Canadian consumers to continue to promote Canadian producers,” Smith said.

“I think farmers work hard in this country, and this is a hit to them.”

READ MORE: NAFTA deal reached — Canada, U.S., Mexico reach trade agreement under new name

The lobby group says the measures will have “a dramatic impact not only for dairy farmers but for the whole sector,” adding that it fails “to see how this deal can be good for the 220,000 Canadian families that depend on dairy for their livelihood.”

Story continues below advertisement

David Wiens with Dairy Farmers of Manitoba is voicing concerns about how the entire farming process may change for him.

“On the farm we make investments to make improvements and expand our facilities in anticipation of market growth,” Wiens said. “It turns out now that may not have been necessary.”

READ MORE: More online shopping but also pricier drugs: What the new NAFTA means for your wallet

The deal may be unpleasant for dairy producers, but it could work out to be favourable for consumers.

Bryce Matlashewski, advisor for National Bank Financial, said the USMCA could lead to better prices at the grocery store.

“Dairy farmers are not going to be too pleased with this deal. It does limit the value of their commodity that they are producing,” Matlashewski said.

“It does mean that there is going to be more supply in Canada, and in theory, that could mean better retail prices on dairy products such as cheese and milk.”

He said although the agreement “may not be the best deal,” it is better than no deal at all, and will put the Canadian economy into a growth mode.

WATCH: Financial advisor says new trade agreement good for consumers

Financial advisor says new trade agreement good for consumers
Financial advisor says new trade agreement good for consumers

-With files from The Canadian Press

Story continues below advertisement